Deficit
Reduction Act of 2005 (DRA) state Medicaid plan amendments
raising cost-sharing & cutting
benefits were approved for ID,
KY & WV and are being sought by IN, LA, MT, NE, NV, OH, OK,
RI, SC & WY. HIFA waivers for
FL & VT were approved.
State officials are studying ways to
reform (either cut or
expand) Medicaid in AR,
CT, FL, GA, ID,
IN,
IA, KS, LA, MD, ME,
MI, MS, MO,
NE, NV,
NH, NM, ND, NY,
OH, OK,
RI, SC,
TN , TX, UT,
VA, WA,
WI &
WY.
Coverage
expanded in
AL,AR,CO,DE,DC,HI,ID,IA,IL,KS,LA,MD,
ME,MA, MO, MT,
NM,
NC, NV, NJ, NY, OH, OK,
PA, RI, TN,
VT,
VA,WV & WY.
States cut
coverage or benefits in AK, AZ, CA, CO, DE, FL,
ID, KS,
KY, MD, ME, MI, MS, MO, NY, NC, OH, OR, TN, WA,
WV & WY.
States have
strict monthly numerical limits on Medicaid Rx’s--in
AL, AR, GA, KY, MS, OK, SC, TN, TX and WV;
but LA & NC eased
their Rx limits.
ADAP
“waiting lists”
& other cost-containment steps are in effect in at least 10
states and extra federal funding
for 1,500+ patients expired on 3/30/06.
TABOR
(“Taxpayer Bill of Rights”) measures that cripple state health
funding are on the 11/06 ballot in ME, NE, OR & possibly MT--and
courts (at least for now) have voided improper TABOR ballot
petitions in several other states.
Congressional
SCHIP funding delays threaten coverage for 500,000+ children in
AK, GA, IL, IA, LA, ME, MD, MA, MN, MO, NE, NJ, NC, RI, SD and
WI.
Alabama--- Has
no spend down; allows only 12 doctor visits &
hospital days yearly and 4 brand name Rx’s monthly (plus unlimited
generics); but new SCHIP applications are again allowed. The 2007
Medicaid budget will be short $200 million.
There’s a very long ADAP waiting list. The state plans to
raise doctor payments. Alabama Blue Cross now offers a discount plan
($167/mo/indiv; $368/mo/fam) to the uninsured not on Medicare, but
with a 12/mo preexisting condition waiting period and big
deductibles ($1,000; $250 for Rx’s) and co-pays.
Alaska---this
Title XVI state, with no spend down, froze its nursing
home income level; cut the CHIP level from 200% to 175% FPL (1,200
families lost children’s care); tightened qualifications for home
care & created a SPAP for the aged but not the
disabled. There’s an ADAP waiting list.
Arizona---a
referendum & waiver gives AHCCES (SCHIP & Medicaid) to all
uninsured parents & children under 200% & to all
(even non-disabled) childless adultsunder 100%. CMS agreed,
before the DRA’s passage, to let the state set the state set
higher co-pays (e.g., $10 per brand name Rx, $5 per generic, $5 per
doctor visit), but a court has-at least so far--blocked them. The
state did raise parental premiums, on a sliding scale based
on income range (only for those with family incomes over
100% FPL) from $45/$85 to $75/$167 monthly.
AZ Blue Cross now covers unmarried
children of non-group policyholders as dependents to age 29
(!), even if they’re not students.
Arkansas---
Gov. Huckabee (R ) raised $100 million in tobacco & income taxes to
save the spend down, Katie Beckett waivers & adult vision care &
preserve nursing home rates. Yet
Medicaid & CHIP payments are too low to attract enough doctors &
dentists; there’s an ADAP waiting list;
and a state committee began studying ways to cut the Medicaid
budget. The state got a HIFA waiver to offer
barebones, Medicaid-funded health
insurance to 50,000 workers & spouses with incomes under 200% ($15
monthly premium; 7 doctor visits & hospital days a year & 2 Rx’s a
month; $100 deductible; 15% coinsurance), also offers the plan for a
$100 monthly premium to 30,000 more with higher incomes; and
raised Medicaid and SCHIP children’s
dental rates to 95% of what the private Delta Dental plan pays.
California---red tape & a lower income level took 200,000 parents
off the rolls since 2004. Gov. Schwarzenegger ( R ) called for
premiums ($4 to $27) for those over 100% or the SSI level,
is forcing the aged & disabled into HMOs, proposed a yearly
patient dental care cap of $1,000; and got legislative consent to a
deal with CMS for $3.3 billion more in DSH federal funds for 5 years
(some say it’s too little & doesn’t offer enough state funds). He
made 5% doctor rate cuts & stopped paying extra Medicare HMO
premiums for dual eligibles; but supported raising SSP levels to
$849 monthly ($1491 a couple); spending $50 million more to expand
CHIP; establishing 500 health clinics in targeted low income
schools; banning balance billing to patients for ER visits; and
compelling drug makers to offer discounts to the moderate
income uninsured. Yet he vetoed the Democratic legislature’s
universal coverage bill.
Colorado---has
no spend down; a court voided a law to deny benefits
to legal aliens & once-blocked CHIP applications are again
accepted. Denver’s Medical Center & the University of Colorado
Hospital cut their in-house indigent care programs & raised their
co-pays. Still, an added $2 million in state funds eased the ADAP
waiting list. Cigarette taxes voted by referendum will raise the
CHIP level from 185% to 200% (enough to cover 4,000 more children),
open 600 more HCB and/or Katie Beckett waiver slots to disabled
children, raise funding for low income clinics & raise the parents’
income level to 60% (enough to cover 90,000 more). HIFA waiver plans
were dropped, but the state will save $59 million by shifting
Medicaid children into HMOs. The legislature, opposed by drug makers
& some consumer groups, plans to adopt a drug formulary to save even
more. The Colorado Indigent Care plan for those not eligible for
Medicaid, such as the childless poor awaiting SSA disability
decisions, raised its co-pays: $10 per Rx, $35 per doctor visit,
$270 per hospital stay & $15 to $45 per ER visit. The state cut its
rates 15% to the ColoradoAccess HMO, which then dumped 65,000 former
enrollees into fee-for-service Medicaid; but
increased funding for the its health
insurance risk pool, allowing more liberal premium discounts for the
poor (a 50% discount if family income is under $$40,000; and 40% if
under $50,000).
Connecticut—a
209(b) state; Governor Rell (R ) added doctor co-pays of $1 to $3;
raised Medicaid’s $1 Rx co-pays to $1.50 & $3; upped SPAP premiums
to $30 & its co-pays to $16.25; imposed a $100,000 SPAP asset test;
required recoveries of SPAP costs from the deceased’s estates;
dropped legal aliens from TANF, Medicaid, CHIP & SAGA
(state-funded welfare & medical programs) and forced SAGA patients
into HMOs; set up a board to study Medicaid “reforms”;
and ended Medicaid coverage of adults’ chiropractic;
naturopathy, occupational, physical/ speech therapy & psychology
care. But the Democratic legislature
raised the parents’ level back up to 150% & repealed Rell’s earlier
family & CHIP premium hikes. Medicaid & CHIP specialist & dentist
rates are too low to attract enough providers, so the state will
raise (only in 2007 and even then just for its first 6 months) most
pediatric dental rates to 70% of private insurers’ payment levels.
The state offers Medicaid to the working disabled and even the
working “recovered/ex-disabled”.
Delaware---has
no spend down, ended its waiver to cover
all adults under 100% (but
still covers parents under 100%) and caps yearly SPAP
benefits. Gov. Minner (D) created a Cancer Treatment Program for the
uninsured not on Medicare with incomes under 650% (!)
& a “CHAP/VIP” state indigent health program for uninsured adults
not on Medicare with incomes under 200%; added $5 million
for caseload growth; and raised provider rates to 65% of private
insurance levels.
District of
Columbia---the locally-funded Health Alliance covers all the
uninsured under 200% except
Medicare & Medicaid eligibles. DC’s Medicaid levels are 100% for the
aged & disabled and 200% for families & children.
A “DC Homes” low income clinic expansion
plan—now widened by outgoing Mayor Williams (D) to a bigger $240
million proposal, with both its original funding & $33 million in
new, windfall tobacco settlement money---will strengthen preventive
health, cancer screening, anti-smoking and ER & ambulance services;
and expand & add more primary health care facilities. DC also
boosted its home health & personal care aide pay rates; added
coverage of adult dental care, raised all its dental
rates & will subsidize indigent dental care at Howard U. Dental
College & low income clinics; and seeks a
$7 million CMS grant (with $14 million in local money) to hire more
school nurses. CMS let DC raise its QMB & SLMB income levels from
100% & 120% FPL to $1809 monthly each---not only making many more
Medicare patients eligible for payment of their Medicare premiums,
deductibles & coinsurance, but thereby also for Part D full subsidy
Extra Help.
Florida---Gov.
Bush (R ) began to outsource Medicaid, welfare & food stamp
eligibility to private firms; and his waiver to privatize Medicaid &
convert it, with premium support & health savings accounts, into a
“defined contribution” HMO-type insurance was approved by CMS (see
Understanding Florida’s Medicaid Waiver Application at
www.wphf.org and also
http://theaidsinstitute.org/downloads/FloridaMedicaidreform.pdf
); a waiver pilot started in 2 counties in September. Even sooner,
43,000 patients over 60 in northern & central counties are being
enrolled in a 2nd waiver that favors home-based care
over nursing homes. The state cut the aged/disabled Medicaid
income eligibility level from $719 to $603 on 1/1/06 (77,000 lost
coverage); set up a Medicaid “reform” board and abolished its
SPAP 1/1/06. A “fail first” rule allows costly mental health drugs
only if cheaper ones don’t work (with Lamictal, Paxil, Wellbutrin,
Lexapro, Zoloft & Zyprexa exempted). The state again covers adult
dentures & hearing aids and takes SCHIP applications anytime instead
of only 2 months a year. Children’s, health , doctor & dentist
groups demanded & then sued to raise children’s care fees and made
the state drop a prior approval rule for nutrition supplements.
The state now plans CHIP cuts of $169 to $219 million; but
Dade County & private donors launched a $40 million plan to fund
school nurses & social workers to offer preventive & simpler,
routine care and enroll potentially eligible students in Medicaid &
SCHIP.
Georgia---ended
CHIP coverage of oral surgery & other dental work and cut the
Medicaid & WIC level for pregnant women (7,500 lost coverage) &
infants from 235% to 200%; raised CHIP premiums to range from $10 to
$35 monthly per child; ended adult coverage of emergency dental care
& artificial limbs; is moving 1 million patients (including 100,000
aged & disabled and 200,000 on CHIP) into HMOs
(causing some without proper transfer
papers to go without coverage) ; ended spend down eligibility
for nursing home care (but use of complex trusts can still retain or
gain eligibility for some); boosted disease management for chronic
cases; dropped adult dental care, orthotics, prosthetics & hospice
care; may even time limit eligibility for breast/cervical cancer
category patients; set up still another
health insurance & Medicaid “reform” board; capped HCB care
costs; and tightened medical
eligibility for Katie Beckett waiver care (which a 2006 supplemental
budget shifts into a public-private body that proponents say
bolsters funding). Gov. Perdue (R ) first sought, then postponed for
at least a year, a HIFA waiver to further cut nursing home access,
raise co-pays (even for children & nursing home patients) and add
more managed care & health savings account features to Medicaid. A
state health board voted to eliminate the 90 day coverage
suspensions for children with parents delinquent in paying CHIP
premiums, but the state’s ADAP may have to
adopt some cost-containment steps. CMS forbade further use of
the accounting gimmicks that have brought in $300 million yearly in
federal funds & questioned $70 million in foster children’s mental
health costs; the state, CMS & hospitals were re-negotiating DSH
costs; and---while rising tax revenues may let the state cut less
than the $269 to $388 million first projected and
the rolls dropped by 60,000 in early 2006
due to tighter eligibility re-determination & document verification
procedures---CHIP may still face a $12 million deficit.
Guam—this US
territory’s Medicaid matching funds are capped by federal law far
below what a state would get. The under-funded non-federal medically
indigent program pays even less than Medicaid & attracts even fewer
providers. Advocates for private managed care firms claim that
letting such contracts with them would save enough money to pay
providers more. Funds for off-island specialty care, and air
transportation to it, are exhausted.
Hawaii—a 209(b)
state; a “Quest” waiver gives Medicaid to parents & uninsured,
childless adults not on Medicare under 200%, except for the
childless aged & disabled, who must be under 100% to get it. The
state requires employers to offer health coverage to employees &
dependents and created a SPAP for
aged and disabled patients, but with an income level
of only 100%. Gov. Lingle (R) raised the parent income level to 250%
(covering 29,000 more); lowered CHIP premiums; restored some adult
dental care through both Medicaid & dental charity programs and
expanded substance abuse care.
Idaho---this
Title XVI state, with no spend down, raised the CHIP
level from 150% to 185% (but with less benefits & more co-pays than
for poorer patients); funded a pilot
barebones health plan for 1,000 adults; and covered the
working disabled. But it cut funds for non-federal medical aid for
the temporarily disabled & those awaiting SSA disability decisions;
ended mandates for private health insurance coverage of breast &
prostate cancer screening & mental health; and got CMS approval to
set up 3 patient classes: Parents & children (with a $13 million
lower yearly care budget & more cost-sharing and/or coverage cuts) ;
the disabled & chronically ill; and the aged. The first (but later
the others too) will face more cost-sharing & there’ll be different
(perhaps lesser) benefits for each class, but with more preventive
care & incentives. See
http://healthandwelfare.idaho.gov/site/3629/default.aspx for a
description. There’s an ADAP waiting list.
Illinois---this
209(b) state’s main SPAP (funded as a Medicaid Pharmacy Plus waiver)
excludes the disabled, who get only a limited
formulary from a 2nd, separate Circuit Breaker SPAP. Gov.
Blagjoievich (D) added HIV drugs to the 2nd formulary
(but only for those on Medicare); raised the family income level to
185%; and got the Democratic Legislature to pass a hospital tax to
fund healthcare. Then they
authorized “universal” SCHIP coverage, with more cost-sharing for
“richer” families; accepted a court order raising children’s doctor,
specialist & EPSDT rates; and offered
subsidized health insurance to uninsured veterans left uncovered by
Administrationl VA cuts. But GOP Governor
candidate Topinka called for $2.9 billion in Medicaid cuts &
stricter eligibility rules for new applicants. To save $1.5
billion projected in a Lewin study, the state began shifting
patients into HMOs to fund the expansions (HMO enrollment had been
voluntary before).
Indiana---this
209(b) state’s SPAP still excludes the disabled;
and, despite court suits, it still has a much-stricter-than-SSI
“209(b)” Medicaid disability rule (one must be fatally or
incurably ill). Gov. Daniels (R ) and the GOP legislature
will double CHIP premiums & cut the HCB waiver budget by $14 million
yet will let Medicare patients into the risk pool for secondary
coverage at discounted rates & add 500 more HCB waiver slots (even
though a KPMG audit found many waiver problems).
There’s now an ADAP waiting list;
and the ACLU filed suit challenging a once-every-6-years-only limit
on dentures & relinings. The state plans to spend $1 billion on a
privatization of food stamp, welfare & Medicaid eligibility that
will close 107 welfare offices with 2,500 workers (now delayed to
allow further federal review); tightened its lax spend down
procedures (too much & too soon, it turned out, after
a class action suit forced the state to accept a court’s consent
order reinstating 12,606 aged & disabled who were cut off without
even the right to hearings); funded service plans for 650 more
disabled clients; is enrolling patients in
managed care plans that, doctors say, will pay even less
than the pittances Medicaid fee-for-service now does, thus further
reducing provider participation and access to primary and
specialist care and inevitably causing unnecessary, costly ER visits;
and is considering a Medicaid expansion
or HIFA waiver
to subsidize (barebones)
health insurance for uninsured working adults under 200%, modeled on
plans of MA, IA, MI or
FL
(see
http://www.in.gov/fssa/programs/healthcare/affordability for the
state’s hearings schedule & issue papers).
Iowa---the
state has a waiver to give watered-down
Medicaid (with premiums up to 5% of income) to up to 30,000
uninsured persons not on Medicare--whether they’re aged, disabled, a
parent or not--with incomes under 200% but only at 2 public
hospitals---but with no uniform statewide waiver drug
benefit: Those who are also prior U. of IA
hospital “state papers” indigent program patients are nominally
grandfathered-in, only for a year & with high co-pays, for its free
drug formulary; while Des Moines-area waiver patients can also
access a Polk County public hospital’s indigent drug formulary; but
drug coverage for other waiver eligibles is sketchy or
non-existent. The ADAP waiting list was only partially & temporarily
served by now-expired extra emergency federal funding and some added
state funds. A legislative committee began to study ways to cut
Medicaid, but
Gov.Vilsack proposed an 80-cent cigarette
tax hike to subsidize barebones
insurance for even more patients---workers with incomes under 200%
who are employed in firms of 25 or less.
Kansas---this
Title XVI state’s SPAP was abolished 1/1/06.
Spurning Gov. Sibelius’ (D) call for more health coverage, the
GOP legislature passed a limited tax credit to expand small firm
coverage, health savings account measures, a health care
re-organization & called for more anti-fraud efforts—but did raise
provider fees from 65% to 83% of Medicare’s rate. Blue Cross & a
foundation subsidize barebones
insurance for Kansas City-area families making under $30,000.
The state may have to impose ADAP cost
containments; is considering higher
co-pays for smokers & the obese and
stricter motorcycle helmet laws & other preventive health
steps; and offers Medicaid to the working
disabled, the working “pre-disabled” (only if they’re in the state
risk pool & have severe impairments) and the working “medically
improved”/ex- disabled”. Because the state plan limited
coverage of disabled institutionalized children to 140/180 days—even
though longer stays are allowed by federal law—CMS questioned
matching for over 500 of them, making the state send them to regular
foster care, small group homes or state hospitals;
a federal audit disallowed $5 million & questioned $127
million more in old Medicaid matching claims for special needs
students; and the state had to refund $14 million in another audit.
Kentucky--- the
state raised Rx co-pays to $1 per generic, $2 per preferred brand
name & $3 per non-preferred brand name drug. But it dropped
earlier-tightened nursing home & HCB care medical qualification
rules; raised the cigarette tax by 30 cents-a-pack (to fund
education & Medicaid) with a
further 10-cent raise under study;
and even reinstated 2,500 formerly-dropped mentally ill clients.
There’s a very long ADAP waiting list.
A $215 million state funds shortfall for 2006, and CMS’ decision to
disallow county hospital, clinic & nursing home budgets as state
matching funds, which will cost the state $100 million, led it to
get CMS approval for: limits
of 4-Rx’s-a-month, 15 occupational/physical/speech therapy
visits-a-year & 12 x-rays/MRIs-a-year (with appeals allowed), $2 to
$10 co-pays for doctor visits, $2 to $20 co-pays for other
outpatient care, $10 to $20 co-pays for non-emergency ER visits,
a whopping $20 to $50 co-pay per hospital stay ; annual
cost-sharing caps of $225 a person & $350 a family (except for
non-Louisville-area patients, who’ll be put into an HMO with a
$450 cost-sharing cap); reduced or no Rx co-pays
for children & for preventive care; and co-pays of $3 per
generic, $10 for “preferred” & $22
for “non-preferred” brand name Rx’s for spend downers. There
will be 4 Medicaid groups: “healthy” adults; children; aged &
disabled adults (including LTC & HCB patients); and the mentally
retarded & developmentally disabled—each with its own benefits &
different, but higher, cost-sharing. See
http://www.kff.org/7530.cfm for details. The state settled a
lawsuit by starting to move 2,500 disabled into HCB care.
Louisiana---the
state cut allowed Rx’s to 8 monthly
(over-ride-able if a doctor certifies medical necessity), cut
its Charity Hospital & school health services, adopted a formulary
and had to take ADAP cost-containment steps.
CMS dropped its claim for a return of $340 million in past matching
funds due to questionable accounting. Hurricanes Katrina & Rita cut
state revenues ($1 billion+ for 2005-06 in a state study; $1 to $3
billion+ in a federal estimate); and left the Charity Hospitals
without sure funding. The Budget Reconciliation bill offers $2.1
billion to pay LA’s & MS’ Medicaid & uncompensated care at a 100%
match; but the state still had to cut its doctor rates by 10%. A
state healthcare recovery & /expansion board
is planning a Medicaid “re-design”;
asked for $400 million in federal funds to restore New Orleans
healthcare; (see
http://www.dhh.louisiana.gov/offices/page.asp?ID=288&Detail=7198
for the state health director’s comments)
and aims to expand coverage (Gov.
Blanco [D] favors the MA plan); but
also to raise cost-sharing. The state indefinitely postponed
183,000 cases’ overdue Medicaid eligibility re-determinations & will
continue their coverage (unless other states report that clients are
now eligible there) until CMS says otherwise. The VA is building a
new $1.2 billion New Orleans hospital that also will somehow take on
much of the city’s destroyed Charity Hospital workload. The state
offers Medicaid to the working “pre-disabled” with mental illnesses
(as well as all the working “fully” disabled)
Maine---the
state subsidizes health insurance for small employers’ workers &
dependents; raised the Medicaid level for the childless--aged,
disabled or not--to 125% (but then barred new childless,
non-disabled, non-aged applicants) & for parents to 200%;
planned coverage of the working disabled; has a waiver to offer
limited Medicaid benefits to HIV+ persons (including the
“pre-disabled”) under 250%; and adopted a formulary (with physician
over-rides allowed). When the health budget faced shortages, the
state raised income taxes on the rich & on tobacco, alcohol, hotels,
restaurants, car rentals & soft drinks to fund health care but also
appointed a commission to study ways to cut Medicaid expenses.
Systems, red tape, accounting & contactor problems have left the
state over one year late in paying many providers.
Maryland---Governor Ehrlich (R ) closed CHIP to new patients
with incomes over 200% ; raised its premiums; and ended Medicaid &
CHIP for legal immigrant children & pregnant women
here less than 5 years. (which the Democratic legislature
reversed---but only effective in 2008). The AARP filed suit saying
the state’s HCB waiver medical admission rules are too strict. The
higher income SPAP excludes the disabled & now only
covers Part D premiums; while the lower income SPAP—and a previous
state-funded program offering only outpatient primary clinic
care--were re-packaged as a Medicaid waiver covering any
non-Medicare-eligible adult under 116%. Specialist & dentist rates
are too low to attract enough providers. The state started a health
insurance risk pool (with premium discounts for the poor) & offered
Medicaid to the working disabled. But in 2005 a state insurance
board let small firm health plans covering 450,000 persons drop
meaningful drug coverage. The legislature overrode Ehrlich’s veto of
a “WalMart” tax on firms that don’t spend at least 8% of revenues on
workers’ health insurance—only to have it voided by a federal court
(the state is appealing).
Massachusetts---almost all of Gov. Romney’s (R ) health cut
proposals (see http://www.kff.org/medicaid/7378.cfm
&
http://www.kff.org/medicaid/7314.cfm for details) failed in or
were reversed by the Democratic legislature. He restored dental care
for women who are pregnant or have children under 3, but called for
tougher work rules even for disabled
welfare clients awaiting SSA disability decisions; limited
state-funded “Free Care” patients to low income clinics; and imposed
$3 clinic & generic drug and $5 ER & brand name drug co-pays on
them. Yet he signed a bill to
expand Medicaid; require all residents to be insured; enact
incentives & subsidies to foster employer coverage; subsidize
health insurancefor those under 300%
(sliding scale premiums per adult will be $18 to $106 monthly);
raise the CHIP level from 200% to 300% (open, with higher premiums &
cost-sharing, to even “richer” families); restore adult Medicaid
dental & eyeglass benefits; raise the parents’ Medicaid level from
133% to 200%; cover more
preventative services; offer premium & co-pay discounts to
non-smokers & preventive cancer screenees;
but fails to raise the childless aged (100%) &
disabled (133%) levels to equal the new 200% parental levels. CMS
approved expansions of Medicaid waivers for the HIV+ (even the
“pre-disabled”) & the childless, non-disabled unemployed; and will
continue a waiver for $385 million yearly in DSH funds. But an HHS
IG audit says the state wrongly claimed $86 million for children’s
targeted case management. See
The Massachusetts Health Reform at
www.communitycalatyst.org on using the plan as a model for
reform in other states.
Michigan---
the state, even with raised tobacco & hospital taxes, still had
to end almost all Medicaid adult dental, hearing aid, podiatry &
chiropractic care and stopped enrolling new childless
non-disabled adults under 100% into its small Medicaid expansion
waiver (which doesn’t cover inpatient care). The House named a
committee to find more Medicaid cuts and the GOP House & Senate
passed bills with more & higher Medicaid & SCHIP premiums & co-pays,
which Gov. Granholm (D) called “unprecedented in [their] cruelty”.
But she signed a bi-partisan compromise to grandfather-in
current recipients; adopt some GOP cost-sharing; impose some
stricter eligibility rules for some new applicants
only; and even require patient urine tests for smoking &
sugary/fatty diets (violators face $10 penalty premiums)--while
restoring adult dental care, raising children’s dental rates to
private-pay levels & vetoing a 4 year welfare time limit. The SPAP
was abolished but Granholm asked CMS for
$600 million more in federal funds for a Medicaid waiver to fund
subsidized, sliding-scale-premium insurance for the working poor &
small firm workers under 200% (to be open at cost to “richer”
persons); and the state raised child wellness fees & adult
preventive care rates 30%. The Detroit/Wayne County Health
Authority began an initiative to enroll over 100,000 new Medicaid &
SCHIP eligibles. A court voided a pre-DRA state law to let providers
make patients actually pay Rx co-pays, but the state Senate voted to
raise cost-sharing still higher.
Minnesota---this 209(b) state raised premiums & co-pays for
Medicaid, CHIP & MinnesotaCare (state-subsidized health insurance),
cut the latter’s income levels and denied Medicaid & CHIP to
legal aliens. While GOP plans to abolish state medical
assistance for the childless unemployed & the disabled awaiting SSA
disability decisions failed, nearly 30,000 still lost MinnesotaCare.
Some other previous MinnesotaCare cuts were restored when
Gov. Pawlenty (R ) & the Democratic Senate agreed on a
75-cents-a-pack cigarette “impact fee”. A court, using pre-DRA
federal Medicaid law, voided a state law letting Medicaid
providers deny care or Rx’s to those who don’t make co-pays, yet
the state’s ADAP began to drop patients who
don’t make its co-pays . The SPAP was abolished
on 1/1/06. But the Governor funded a
$2.5 million Rx discount plan for the uninsured & Part D donut hole
patients; $4.5 million more for the
state SHIP; and Medicaid for the working
“pre-disabled” and “recovered/ex-disabled” (as well as the working
fully disabled).
Mississippi---has no spend down; Gov. Barbour (R ) cut
the monthly aged/disabled income level from over $1,000 to $603 on
1/1/06 (65,000 lost Medicaid) & cut CHIP eligibility (up to 2,500
children were dropped); and a state board began studying more
Medicaid “reforms”. Brand name drugs were cut to 2
monthly plus 3 generics (but HIV patients get 5
brand name drugs; there’s a suit challenging the limits); and, using
prior authorization & utilization rules, physical, speech &
occupational therapy were cut. A state study put its Katrina tax
losses at $213 to $272 million+ just for 2005’s last quarter. While
the Budget Reconciliation bill offers $2.1 billion for MS’ & LA’s
Medicaid & uncompensated care costs at a 100% match,
CMS banned further use of a doubtful state funding scheme,
forcing Barbour to propose $360 million—later revised to $45
million, then $90 million-- in new hospital taxes.
Newly-required face-to-face interviews for both initial &
re-determination applications and stricter document verifications
caused the rolls to drop by 50,000.
Missouri---a
209(b) state; Gov. Blunt (R ) & the GOP legislature cut the
aged/disabled income level from 100% to 85%; ended state medical aid
& welfare for those awaiting SSA disability decisions; dropped
coverage of the working disabled; cut the parents’ level to 23% from
75% (but a court reinstated those who also qualify in the
welfare-to-work, disabled or aged categories); ended adult dental,
podiatry, hearing aid, crutches, wheelchair maintenance, walker &
eyeglass benefits (but a federal appeals court let a suit proceed
challenging the denial of catheters, bedrails & other medical
equipment to the disabled); enacted new & bigger Medicaid co-pays;
raised CHIP premiums, made 46,000 more children pay them; denied
CHIP to those seemingly able to get “affordable” work coverage, even
if it’s really too costly (20,000 lost CHIP; but a public outcry got
the state to exempt families with work plan premiums over 5% of
income); and tightened medical rules to get nursing home, HCB & home
health care. Yet CHIP co-pays were ended, doctor & nursing homes
rates were raised & the SPAP was expanded to cover the
disabled (except those in the 2
year waiting period). Blue Cross &
a foundation subsidize insurance for Kansas City-area families
earning under $30,000. The state’s ADAP had
to take cost-containment steps. A state Medicaid “reform”
committee called for different benefit packages for families &
children, the disabled and the aged; more cost-sharing; and more
preventive care The state Senate---but not the House—voted to
restore coverage of the working disabled (but with a very low extra
unearned income test that severely limits
eligibility); and the state did restore coverage of eyeglasses &
wheelchair supplies. A state poll reports
66% favor a 11/06 referendum (see
www.peoplesagendafund.org &
www.gromo.org ) to raise tobacco taxes to restore all
the Medicaid cuts & raise the Medicaid income level to 200%,
which Blunt & GOP legislative leaders
oppose. He now refuses to call a special session to complete
legislative action on the working disabled restoration bill.
A documentary film, Out of Sight, Out
of Mind, portrays the cuts’ effects on patients; contact
paul@RagTagFilm.com (573)
443-4359 for showings & availability.
Montana---the
state added more & bigger co-pays, restricted nursing home
eligibility, cut doctor visits for the aged & disabled to 10 yearly,
dropped coverage of some hospice & home health care --but found
money to end the CHIP waiting list & cover 2,000 more children. The
state’s “Passport to Health” & Team Care programs save over $20
million yearly by assigning primary care doctors to patients to
reduce ER & hospital costs; and it created tax breaks & buying pools
to help small firms insure workers. The
state seeks a HIFA
waiver to fund a higher CHIP income level
to cover 10,000 more children & give
barebones Medicaid to 3,000 more
adults; raised Medicaid’s family & children non-home asset
level to $15,000 (letting it switch 3,800 children from SCHIP, which
has a capped budget, to Medicaid, which doesn’t), and thus free
those SCHIP slots to cover more uninsured children; and
created a SPAP to pay up to $33.11 in Part D premiums for
aged and disabled Medicare patients under 200%
(but it won’t pay any deductibles, co-pays or
coinsurance or for drugs uncovered by Part D plans, nor
cover the disabled in the 2 year waiting period).
There’s an ADAP waiting list.
Nebraska----this Title XVI state
ended coverage for 15,000 welfare-to-work parents (but a US District
Court order voiding much of the cut was upheld in 5/06 by the
Circuit Court of Appeals) & childless, non-disabled 19 &
20-year-olds. There’s an ADAP waiting list.
The state will pay
Part D co-pays for dual eligibles in HCB waiver programs and board &
care and group homes. A state board seeks to save Medicaid $72
million a year by making it a “defined contribution” plan
& promoting assisted living & HCB waivers over nursing home
care (see
http://www.hhs.state.ne.us/med/reform/ ).
Nevada---this
Title XVI state, with no spend down, raised $1 billion
in new taxes to fund Medicaid; added
coverage of the working disabled;
boosted the pregnant women’s level from 133% to 185%; raised the
income level & covered the disabled (including
those in the 2 year wait) for its SPAP;
will use DSH & CHIP funds (with a
HIFA waiver) & a CMS risk pool
grant for barebones
insurance for small firm workers & families (employers would pay 50%
of costs & workers would get a $100/mo premium subsidy);
added limited adult dental & vision care;
boosted state ADAP funding; raised CHIP
premiums; rejected adding Medicaid co-pays for Rx’s & other
care; and set up a board to study more reforms.
New
Hampshire---a 209(b) state; Governor Lynch (D) promoted CHIP
enrollment; added $180,000 to ADAP; signed a tobacco tax increase
to fund health costs; is considering a $2 million boost in home care
rates; and plans to hire a contractor to “coordinate” & foster
cheaper, better care for costly cases. The state still has a
stricter-than-SSI “209(b)” Medicaid disability rule (inability to
work for at least 4 years) and
its ADAP had to adopt cost-containment
measures.
New Jersey---in
2001-04 the state had to cut the parents’ income level, drop
legal aliens, stop paying hospital bills in its state-only
program for those awaiting SSA disability decisions and privatize
eligibility determinations for CHIP, FamilyHealth & Medicaid. But by
2005 it began moving the parental level back up to 133% (covering
80,000 more parents), sought a waiver to cover all (even
non-disabled) adults under 100%; and will offer
at-home/in-the-community care as alternatives to nursing homes. The
legislature & Gov. Corzine (both Democratic) passed a compromise
bill with a 1% sales tax increase---but
not with the $620-per-bed hospital tax he sought to
bolster Medicaid. A federal audit said $52 million in funds that the
state claimed for school health care for special needs students was
inadequately documented.
New Mexico—has
no spend down; its barebones
Medicaid waiver-funded health insurance for uninsured adults under
200% excludes Medicare patients. The state seems to have
quietly dropped proposed plan changes & waivers to impose co-pays of
$2 per Rx, $5 per office visit, $15 per ER visit & $25 per hospital
stay, an “enrollment fee” of $25 & a $10 annual premium; cut
coverage of rural transport costs to get Rx’s; end coverage of adult
eyeglasses & other medical equipment; and stop coverage for illegal
aliens. And Gov. Richardson changed eligibility re-certifications to
once instead of twice yearly; raised income levels enough (to 235%)
to cover 7,800 more children & 1,200 more pregnant women; and
chose a task force to plan expanding
coverage (modeled on the MA reforms); raising the Medicaid waiver
level to 300% to cover more modest income workers; and giving
Medicaid to all (even childless & non-disabled) adults
under 100%.
New York---a
“Family Health” waiver covers parents under 150% & all childless
(even non-disabled) adults under 100% except
childless Medicare patients (who must be under the lower SSI/SSP
level to get Medicaid). State-subsidized “Healthy NY”
insurance for workers under 250% excludes part timers & Medicare
patients & caps yearly Rx’s at $3,000.
The state still excludes the disabled from its SPAP,
even though Part D will save it over $113 million yearly;
began forcing SSI recipients into HMOs; raised FamilyHealth co-pays
to $5 for doctors & dentists & to $3 for generic & $6 for brand name
Rx’s; raised other Medicaid Rx co-pays to $1 per
generic & $3 for brands; capped yearly Medicaid co-pays at $200; set
up a formulary allowing doctor over-rides; is starting & seeking a
waiver for Medicaid assisted living, chore aide & adult day care
instead of costlier nursing homes; requested a waiver extension to
keep letting HMOs & clinics enroll patients; but cut the
aged/disabled couple Medicaid income level by $75 monthly. The state
makes the City & its counties pay half of non-federal Medicaid
costs, but it capped those local costs to a 3.5% increase. It raised
Family Health ER co-pays to $25; let providers deny services to
those who don’t meet co-pays); enacted slightly tighter nursing home
rules for asset transfers (but did not tighten living
allowances, spousal support & asset rules for home-based & HCB
waiver care); funded AIDS day care health centers; set up a new
health foundation to spend $250 million the state got from Empire
Blue Cross’ charity-to-profit conversion on promoting access for the
poor & preventive medicine, diabetes, diet & fitness programs; and
created a new Medicaid coverage category for the uninsured with
colon or prostate cancer with incomes under 250% (fully state-funded
for those over 150% or otherwise not federally-matchable and
reportedly even available secondarily to Medicare patients). State
law requires hospital bill discounts for those with incomes under
300% & bans taking homes for delinquent bills. An Assembly study
said prior authorization procedures wrongly deny/delay patients’
access to needed walkers, wheelchairs & other medical equipment.
North
Carolina---added coverage of the working disabled (to
be effective 7/1/07); increased covered Rx’s from 6 to
8 monthly (with exceptions for serious conditions; 3 more allowed
through pharmacists; and even more as allowed by a medication
therapy management program); and abolished its SPAP 1/1/06. CMS
forced cuts of $80 million in HCB care & home aides for 5,000
disabled persons; the state will make up $30 million of that with
school funds & reorganize financing of public behavioral health
(with $75 million more for community health centers). The UNC
hospital system eased some eligibility rules for free indigent care,
but now requires up-front co-pays.
Children’s orthodonture & dental rates are
too low to attract enough providers. The state makes its
counties pay 15% of Medicaid costs but Gov. Easley & the legislature
(both Democratic) froze county costs for 2006-07;
authorized doubling the ADAP income level to 250%, if and as federal
funding allows (a rise to 200% may be possible); but
cut funds for kindergarteners’ eye exams by 75%. A federal audit
requires the state to refund $15.5 million (plus $90 million more
from hospitals) in over-claimed DSH funds.
North
Dakota---this 209(b) state established a Medicaid “reform”
commission.
Ohio---this
209(b) state cut the parental income level from 100% to 90% (27,000
lost Medicaid 1/1/06); raised Rx co-pays to $3; slashed the adult
dental care budget by 50%; ended adult vision, podiatry &
psychologist care; cut secondary payments for dual eligibles; herded
all non-Medicare patients into HMOs; slashed $80 million from the
non-federal Disability Medical Assistance (DMA) program for 15,000+
disabled persons awaiting SSA eligibility decisions; and
let providers refuse service to those who
don’t meet co-pays. Yet it created over 2,000 new HCB waiver
slots; beefed up its home care programs (which cost one-fifth of
nursing home prices) and moved 700+ patients into that care; and
GOP majority legislators proposed covering
the working disabled. Ohio’s $504 monthly aged/disabled level
is already the nation’s lowest. Outgoing
Gov. Taft (R ) still wants $2 billion more in cuts &
transferred $200 million+ in left-over TANF funds to day care, home
energy assistance & other low income programs,
but nothing to Medicaid. No
new DMA applications are being taken; and current DMA patients must
“prove” they need medical care or lose coverage.
Oklahoma---this
209(b) state cut the Medicaid level from 185% to 100% for children
over 1 & from 100% to the much lower SSI/SSP level for the aged &
disabled, ended the family spend down,
re-imposed a “3-Rx’s-a-month” limit and cut the nursing home
& HCB waiver income level---but Gov. Henry (D) added coverage of the
breast & cervical cancer and working disabled groups. Higher tobacco
taxes fund a HIFA waiver to
subsidize barebones insurance for
50,000+ workers & spouses, with incomes under 185%, in firms with
under 50 workers (Henry hopes to expand the program) ;
and the state mental health agency coordinates early
intervention & treatment services for at-risk school pupils in 30
counties. Gov. The state plans to
cut $100 million in fraud & abuse; change
Medicaid into a defined contribution plan with a 2nd
(Florida-type) HIFA waiver; offer fewer,
“customized”, cheaper benefits; pay premium support instead of
secondary, wraparound Medicaid if patients can get work coverage;
promote health savings accounts; end private insurance benefits
mandates; cut ER & nursing home costs by promoting primary
care and community & clinic care; raise provider fees;
further expand mental health care (with
some help from a federal grant); allow & fund more nurse
practitioner care; and require the covering of students on parents’
private insurance to age 23. But the state
ADAP had to adopt severe cost-containments.
Oregon---a
Title XVI state with no spend down; an anti-tax
referendum caused 70,000+ childless, non-SSI adults to lose coverage
via income level cuts & premium raises & ended spend down
eligibility for all but transplant & HIV patients (Oregon Health
Plan enrollment fell over 50%). In 2004-05, the state limited adult
dental care; ended adult vision coverage; limited urban non-HMO
in-hospital days to 18 yearly; and adopted more ADAP cost
containment steps.
Pennsylvania---funding shortages limit enrollment for
state-subsidized barebones
“AdultBasic” health insurance for uninsured adults under 200% (it
excludes Medicare patients & has no drug
benefit). The state’s SPAP still
fails to cover the disabled under age 65--even though Part D could
save it $170 million a year (the state is finalizing
legislation for the SPAP to wraparound Part D & pay its premiums &
cost-sharing for joint eligibles). The state
imposed premiums of $40+ monthly plus more & higher co-pays
on Katie Becket waiver children whose families make over $40,000. It
cut covered inpatient hospital stays to twice a year (but only once
yearly for General Assistance patients), inpatient rehabilitation
stays to once a year and doctor & clinic visits to 18 a year for
male adults; rejected higher co-pays & monthly numerical limits for
prescriptions; but may have to take ADAP
cost containment steps. Gov.
Rendell (D) got $85 million more from state Blue Cross plans for the
AdultBasic budget to cover 30,000 of the 120,000+ on its waiting
list; but they (which are CHIP contractors) were caught improperly
enrolling children in their own more costly $50-premium
“Special” plans (which don’t have dental, vision, hearing or drug
coverage) instead. The 2007 budget raises hospital, nursing home &
HMO contractor rates 4%; gives $5 million to hospital burn units;
and funds “universal” SCHIP coverage, with
more cost-sharing for “richer” families. The state offers
Medicaid to the working disabled & the working
“recovered/ex-disabled”.
Rhode
Island---the state has an 185% parental/family income level;
added limited coverage of the disabled over 55 to its
limited-formulary SPAP and offered Medicaid to the working disabled.
Gov. Carcieri (R ) set up a Medicaid
“reform” board; proposed dropping 3,000 alien children,
tightening eligibility & cutting benefits; yet
signed a bill to subsidize insurance for
some low-paid workers in small firms
(but which also weakened the state’s
mandated health insurance benefits law).
A state court voided his introduction of $1 & $3 Medicaid drug
co-pays without legislative approval.
South
Carolina---has no spend down. The state cut Medicaid
Rx’s from 4 to 3 monthly; added $40 co-pays
for inpatient hospitalizations, $25 for ER visits, $2 for
doctor visits, $3 for dentists, $3 for medical equipment & $1 for
other providers (Rx co-pays were already $3); and
seeks CMS waivers to introduce Medicaid
health savings accounts and raise co-pays more (e.g., $5 per Rx,
$100 per hospital stay, $25 per outpatient surgery).
The SPAP has a 200% income limit; is funded as a Pharmacy
Plus Medicaid waiver; excludes
the disabled; and now covers
all but 5% coinsurance of drug costs for Part D patients under 200%
after they reach the donut hole (10% coinsurance for those with
incomes between 135% and 150%). But its
ADAP---which gets only 4% of its funds from the state—now has a
growing waiting list and is $3 million short. The state plans
to re-impose asset tests for families & children (1 vehicle & 1 home
of any value + $20,000) and has delayed
Medicaid/SCHIP coverage of the new HPV vaccine, although the federal
children’s vaccine program can offer it..
South
Dakota---has no spend down; plans a high risk health
insurance pool & its ADAP had to adopt
cost-containments.
Tennessee----ended its Tenncare waiver expansion, dropping 191,000+
aged, disabled, parents & “uninsurable” adults; but no children.
Except for pregnant women, children & HIV+ persons, Medicaid
doctor’s visits are limited to 10 yearly, hospital days to 20 & Rx’s
to 2 brand names plus 3 generics monthly (with $3 co-pays &
exceptions for HIV & Hepatitis C drugs). The state adopted a
formulary; set Medicaid ER co-pays at $5 (and $5 for some brand name
Rx’s); covered Weight Watchers; and ended methadone coverage. It
budgeted $20 million more for low income & county clinics (with
co-pays of only $5) and adopted ADAP cost
containment measures. But with these savings & $50 million in
now-re-programmed federal DSH money,
the state will raise Medicaid levels for pregnant women &
infants; add hundreds of HCB waiver slots; raise the CHIP income
level to 250%; subsidize
barebones
health insurance for the working poor (yet most
aged & disabled who lost Tenncare can’t work); revive
a high risk pool (with premiums of $5,700+ yearly—with further
premium subsidy discounts for those under 200%
but not for “richer” Medicare patients); and
sponsor Rx discounts on generics & some (but not all) brand name
drugs for those under 250%. But the new
CHIP co-pays are $5 for generic & $20 for brand name drugs; $15 per
doctor visit; $50 per ER visit; and $100 per hospital stay., with a
5 Rx monthly limit (except for insulin, diabetic supplies & some
mental illness drugs).See
www.tenncare.org for details & critiques. Yet the state ended
Medicaid & CHIP coverage of benzodiazepines & barbiturates (even
for anxiety, epilepsy, seizure & mental illnesses,
over-riding its own pharmacy committee).
Photos & bios of
disabled patients who lost Tenncare are at
http://www.joonpowell.info/tenncare.html
. See
www.HealthAffairs.org
(4/25/06) for
an “Interview With a Tenncare Advocate” [Gordon Bonnyman] for the
real reasons for Tenncare’s “failure” & the cuts.
Texas—The state
ended its family-only spend down & CHIP coverage of prostheses,
physical therapy & private duty nursing; tightened CHIP asset rules;
imposed $10 to $20 co-pays for CHIP doctor visits & Rx’s; raised
CHIP premiums; imposed a 90 day wait to enroll in CHIP; cut
Medicaid home health care; and ended adult chiropractic & podiatry
coverage. But a state law denying Medicaid to parents who abuse
drugs or alcohol or whose children miss school or checkups was
voided by a court. The state set up a Medicaid “reform” board &
wants a waiver to force TANF children & families in 8 large counties
into HMOs that will spend $109 million less on their care
each 2 years, but complex hospital rate issues delayed similar HMO
contracts for the aged & disabled. The state’s food stamp, welfare &
Medicaid privatization contractor’s red tape & service was so poor
(100,000 children lost Medicaid or SCHIP since 11/05), that the
state suspended the contract, asked some of the 2,900 laid-off state
eligibility workers state workers to return and gave 30,000 CHIP
cases more time to finish applications & re-certifications.
Texas ADAP had to take cost-containment measures, but eased
access to Fuzeon; and the legislature restored Medicaid & CHIP
mental health, vision & hearing aid coverage & CHIP dental care.
After a federal court first found the state in violation of its
order for better EPSDT outreach, a federal appeals court refused to
kill the suit that had led to the order. The state revoked its
family planning contract with Planned Parenthood (because it uses
private funds for abortions), and is using inexperienced general
clinics instead. Gov. Perry (R ) & the GOP
legislature still refuse to release $256 million collected from
surcharges on Texas electric bills meant to pay 10% to 20% of
Medicaid & food stamp recipients’ electric bills until the
legislature authorizes it in January---and even then may divert the
money to fund more Medicaid
spending or just shore up the
general state budget instead.
Utah---this
Title XVI state, with a HIFA
waiver, gives
barebones Medicaid (no hospital,
specialists’, nursing home or home health care; high drug & other
co-pays; see
http://www.kff.org/medicaid/kcmu030706pkg.cfm for a critique) to
all uninsured adults under 150% & not on Medicare;
offers regular, full Medicaid to the aged & disabled under
100%; but ended adult coverage of podiatry; audiology; speech,
occupational & physical therapy, plus vision & dental care. Even
with a $1 billion state surplus, the GOP legislature still
won’t re-fund the dental and vision benefits (so Gov. Huntsman [R]
actually had to solicit private donations to do so!); and the
legislature also won’t raise doctor fees (now too low to attract
enough providers) or add more special services for the severely
disabled. A legislative committee is again
looking at ways to further cut Medicaid & other safety net programs
.The state’s ADAP had to take cost-containment steps.
Vermont—The
Democratic legislature reversed Gov. Douglas’ (R ) elimination of
adult dental care. But CMS & the legislature approved
his HIFA waiver which, in exchange
for $400 million extra to meet a 5 year deficit, forces patients
into HMOs, promotes HCB care over nursing homes & tightens up asset
transfer bans-- but also caps future federal funds. See
http://www.kff.org/medicaid/7540.cfm for details. A new,
bi-partisan law cuts family premiums by 50%, raises tobacco taxes
and charges $365 to employers that don’t offer health insurance to
fund state-subsidized, non-barebones,
private health insurance for those under 300% starting in
2007. The state also dropped its former,
low unearned income threshold level, which had effectively barred
most of the working disabled with SSDI & VA checks from Medicaid.
Virginia---a
209(b) state; in 2004 $1.3 billion in new business & tobacco taxes
prevented CHIP & Medicaid cuts; raised hospital, nursing home &
dental rates; funded 850 more HCB waiver slots; and covered 100,000
more children. Gov. Kaine (D) authorized
Medicaid for the working disabled & appointed a board to strengthen
Medicaid & explore coverage expansion (its interim report is at
http://www.dmas.virginia.gov/ab-mrc_home.htm ),
but the GOP legislature wants
to create Medicaid health savings accounts, force more patients into
HMOs (half are already) and raise their cost-sharing.
Washington---the state reinstated 12 month Medicaid eligibility for
children after over 20,000 lost coverage; dropped legal
aliens from Medicaid & CHIP (but later began reinstating many); cut
Basic Health (state-subsidized barebones
insurance for those not on Medicare or Medicaid) enrollment by
30,000 & raised its premiums & co-pays. Eligibility tightening
removed 63,000 patients from Medicaid & CHIP and the state set up
a Medicaid “reform” board; but it dropped plans for
children’s Medicaid premiums; restored limited adult dental care;
and is using a $14 million federal funds windfall to pay co-pays for
Part D Extra Help patients through 12/06. Facing a $500 million
budget increase for Medicaid & related programs in 2007-09, and a
state audit finding $1 billion in past improper Medicaid
spending (including $9.5 million in federal funds wrongly spent on
illegal aliens’ non-emergency care), Gov. Gregoire (D)
will tighten administrative & prescription controls; adopt case
management for chronic, costly cases; and, with a facility
development grant from RWJ & presumably a CMS waiver, soon cover
assisted living facility care through Medicaid.
West
Virginia---the state adopted a monthly limit of 4 brand name drugs
and there’s an ADAP waiting list.
The state started a health insurance risk pool yet cut medical
equipment, transport, incontinence, & wheelchair supply funds and
tightened admission criteria –which
it later rescinded—for HCB waiver
care (slots dropped from 5,000 to 3,500). Gov. Manchin (D)
signed bills passed by the Democratic legislature to offer primary
care only (no specialist or hospital coverage) to the uninsured
working (but not unemployed) poor for 3
years (but only with employer support) for $1 co-pays at 8 clinics,
sponsor cheap, barebones subsidized
health insurance for the working poor; and raise the
CHIP income level from 200% to 300%--all to be effective in 2007
(yet then sought to delay the CHIP income
liberalization for at least a year). A new rule
requires prior authorization even for oxygen &
breathing machines, as was already true for adult diapers. The state
got CMS approval to assign primary physicians to patients, place
them in managed care and offer them an extra “bonus” Medicaid
package (“emergent” adult dental care;
uncapped drug coverage; some extra services; preventive,
anti-smoking, diabetes, fitness & diet services; etc.). At first
enrollment in the extra bonus component will be “voluntary”, and
just for non-disabled parents & children (but it might later cover
the disabled & aged too) who sign “personal responsibility”
contracts--with bonus services denied to non-signers & contract
breakers (who’d then face more cost-sharing). See
http://www.kff.org/medicaid/7529.cfm for plan details as first
understood;
http://www.georgetown.edu &
http://www.cbpp.org/5/31-06health.htm on children’s provisions;
and
http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/355/8/753 &
http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/355/8/756 for two NEJM
analyses of the state’s Medicaid plan changes.
Wisconsin---the
state began covering prenatal & childbirth costs of illegal aliens;
got its Pharmacy Plus waiver funding its SPAP (with a 240% income
level & which still excludes the disabled) extended to
6/30/07; but CMS now wants better proof of its cost neutrality. The
state is moving 25% of nursing home patients into cheaper “Family
Care” (at home & in HCB waiver care). Gov.
Doyle (D) vetoed the GOP legislature’s health savings account bill;
wants to raise the children & parent income level from 185% to 200%
(with premiums for those over 150%);
and let “richer” families enroll at full cost.
Wyoming---has
no spend down; the state SPAP is open to anyone
under 100% --aged, disabled or not---who’s not
Medicare-eligible. A state committee is considering more cuts to
Medicaid. The GOP legislature cut the mental health (including
children’s hospital care) & substance abuse budget by nearly half
(even though there’s a $1 billion surplus & a Healthy Together
chronic case management program saves $30 million yearly);
authorized a waiver to give
watered-down
coverage to parents of CHIP children under 200% (with
higher co-pays but premium-free for
those under 133%); and a Katie Beckett waiver to offer
limited services to mentally ill children in working poor & lower
middle income families.
SOURCES AND
RESOURCES:
For the
48 states & DC, the 2006 federal
poverty level (FPL) is $9800
yearly ($817 monthly) for one
plus $3400 yearly ($283 monthly) for each additional person;
see the Asst. Secy. for Plan. & Eval. pages at
www.dhhs.gov for AK & HI.
See
“State Assistance
Programs for SSI Recipients, 2005” at
www.ssa.gov/policy for states’
Medicaid eligibility rules for SSI recipients; 209(b) status;
whether states have (and the amounts of and who administers) any
SSPs; medically needy coverage; and state-SSA welfare interim
assistance reimbursement agreements
for indigents awaiting SSI.
See
“Medicaid and SCHIP
Eligibility for Immigrants” (4/06) at
http://www.kff.org/medicaid/upload/7492.pdf
on limits for federally-matched Medicaid
and SCHIP coverage of both legal and illegal aliens.
See
www.kff.org/medicaidbenefits
for states’ 2003-04 “optional”
coverage of chiropractors, podiatry,
dentistry, dentures, orthodonture,
eyeglasses, optometry, hearing aids, audiologists, psychologists,
prosthetics, medical equipment, hospices and physical, occupational,
speech & other therapy, which
some states later cut in 2004-05.
See
“Outline on State
Medicaid Cutbacks & Responsive Advocacy” at
www.healthlaw.org for
legal rules states must meet to make cuts and legal arguments to
oppose them. Guides and policy arguments for opposing state cuts
appear at www.familiesusa.org
, www.cbpp.org ,
www.communitycatalyst.org &
www.TAEP.org .
See these DRA
advocacy guides,
at
www.healthlaw.org
: “The Role of
State Law in Limiting Medicaid Changes” for
a state-by-state analysis of state
statutes on who can change state Medicaid plans (i.e., to raise
cost-sharing or reduce benefits), “Q and A: State
Medicaid Plans” on preparation &
submission rules & procedures for state plan amendments and
”The Deficit Reduction Act of 2005: Implications for
State Advocacy” for tips to prevent
such plan amendments. See
http://www.nachc.com/advocacy/Files/state-policy/model520state520legislationh.pdf
and
http://www.nachc.com/advocacy/Files/ModelStateLegislation-AppropriationsRiderssr031406_RS-.pdf
for a model statute requiring that plan changes/waivers be
approved by legislatures & not just by Governors or Medicaid
agencies.
See
“Waiver Watch” at
www.healthlaw.org , “Waiver Tool Box” at
www.familiesusa.org & “Coverage Gains Under Recent Section 1115
Waivers” 8/05 at
www.kff.org for news & details on
state waivers.
See
“ADAP Watch” at
www.NASTAD.org for
the latest details on state ADAP
waiting lists, cost containment measures & state ADAP websites.
The “National ADAP Monitoring Report, 2006: Key ADAP Highlights”,
Chart 1, pp.1-2, at
www.kff.org lists
all
state ADAP income levels. See
the adjacent full Report
for their
cost sharing measures and any medical criteria and/or prior
authorization needed for special
or costly drugs. State ADAP
formularies are in a 2nd adjacent document.
See
http://www.kff.org/hivaids/upload/7531.pdf
for a side-by-side comparing the current
Ryan White CARE Act to pending & proposed reauthorization bills;
email
weaids@ticann.org
for “A Beginner’s Guide to the ADAP Program Crisis.”
and
email
alefert@nastad.org for a chart
outlining state ADAPs’ initial responses to an interim survey on
their policies & procedures to coordinate with /wrap-around Part D
.
States’
8/ 2003 cost-sharing, premium & co-pay
rules & amounts are in
“Medicaid and SCHIP: States’ Premium
and Cost Sharing” (03/04) at
http://www.GAO.gov/new.items/d04491.pdf ;
but there’s
more recent
drug co-pay
data in the
“State Medicaid Prescription Drug Reimbursement Chart– March, 2005”
at
www.ascp.com . Also see “Cost-Sharing and Premiums: Shifting
Costs to Those Who Can Afford It Least” (2006) at
www.familiesusa.org for opposing
excessive state cost-sharing, especially as now allowed by the DRA.
See
“Pharmaceutical Benefits
Under State Medical Assistance Programs, 2004” (Section 4, pp.
24-46) under “Resources” at
www.npcnow.org on state
formularies, payments, over-the-counter coverage, prior
authorization, prescribing/dispensing limits & drug co-pay
amounts & any cumulative co-pay caps.
See
http://www.ncsl.org/programs/health/SPAPCoordination.htm &
http://www.medicare.gov/spap.asp on
State Pharmacy Assistance Programs’ (SPAP) eligibility & coverage
and how they coordinate
with/supplement Part D.
See
http://www.medicareadvocacy.org/AlertPDFs/07.21.05.PartDSpeak.full.pdf
for a Glossary of Part D terms;
“The New Medicare Drug
Benefit: How Much Will You Pay?” at
http://www.familiesusa.org/issues/medicare/rx-drug-center/benefit-basics.html
for charts on Part D premiums,
deductibles and co-pays/coinsurance---plus income & asset
levels---for Low Income Subsidies(LIS)/Extra Help;
http://www.nsclc.org/news/06/08/advexcept_081706.doc for a guide
to Part D exceptions & appeals; and
http://www/nsclc.org/news/06/08/compPDPMA_081606.doc to compare
Medicare Advantage (MA) & individual drug plans’ (PDPs) enrollment,
disenrollment & eligibility procedures.
See
http://www.epocrates.com (subscription required) for
regularly updated formularies for each
Part D drug plan.
While Part D
displaces Medicaid for most drugs for dual eligibles,
those 6 narrow classes of drugs that
are specifically excluded by Part D can still be covered for
them by Medicaid; such state coverage is re-tabulated from CMS
surveys at
www.medicareadvocacy.org/Part D_ExcludedDrugsbyState.htm
(12/1/05 report under “News”
icon).
See
“Individual Budget-Based Models of LTC’ (1/06) at
www.statehealthfacts.org for
states’ coverage of HCB waiver, home health, personal care aide &
patient-directed home-based care as alternatives to
institutionalization.
A list of current (2006) state-set personal needs allowance (PNA)
amounts for Medicaid patients in skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) &
intermediate care facilities (ICFs) and for residents in
state-licensed, State Supplementary Payment (SSP)-funded board and
care supervised group homes is available from
lsmetanka@nccnhr.org .
Materials on state TABOR (“Taxpayer Bill of Rights”) state
constitutional amendment ballot measures that artificially restrain
and/or reduce state health, social services, public safety &
education funding are available at
www.cbpp.org .
See
www.healthlaw.org for “
Painless Ways
To Deal With State Medicaid Shortfalls”
(without cutting
eligibility or benefits); state eligibility income levels and rules
in “States With..High Aged/Disabled ..Income Levels”
and “States With High
Parental..Income Levels”; a
health and Medicaid policy
“Glossary”;
State Pharmacy Assistance Programs’
coverage of the disabled & their income levels in “SPAPs,
Part D & Coverage of the Disabled”; “How States Can Make More
Patients Eligible for Pt. D Extra
Help at Little or No State
Cost”; and an introduction to
eligibility for “VA Health..Benefits”.
|