|
EMERGING ISSUES AND DEVELOPMENTS AT THE REGIONAL LEVEL:
SOCIO-ECONOMIC MEASURES TO ALLEVIATE POVERTY IN RURAL AND URBAN
AREAS
(Item 6 (c)
of the provisional agenda)
EMPOWERMENT OF WOMEN IN ASIA AND THE PACIFIC
Note by the secretariat
http://www.unescap.org/55/e1133e.htm
|
SUMMARY
Empowerment of women in the economic and social
fields constitutes one of the fundamental objectives
of all development efforts in the region. Following
the adoption of the Jakarta Declaration for the
Advancement of Women in Asia and the Pacific (1994),
and the Beijing Declaration and the Platform for
Action (1995), significant achievements have been
made in empowering women in the region. Their
economic participation has shown uneven but steady
progress with gender differentials in wages falling
in many instances. Significant progress has also
been made in terms of increases in female literacy
and life expectancy rates, and reduction in
mortality rates. A growing number of women are also
succeeding in the use of new and innovative
technologies, especially information technologies,
and empowering themselves through effective
participation in national machineries and
non-governmental organizations (NGOs). However,
formidable challenges exist, many of which have been
compounded by the present economic crisis and the
adjustment process. Women are facing increased
lay-offs and redundancies and are falling back on
the informal sector and the rural sector for
economic survival. An increasing number of women are
being trafficked for sexual exploitation and forced
labour, with growing incidents of violence against
women. Many migrant women face the bleak prospects
of unemployment when they return home. Although
significant progress has been made in alleviating
poverty in the region, the women in poverty continue
to suffer from economic hardship and social
exclusion. With the changing demographic structure
of the region and increase in the proportion of
older persons, especially older women, the need for
appropriate policies and systems to provide economic
and social support will be an important issue.
Promoting the greater participation of women in
decision-making will continue to be a formidable
challenge. The task of social and economic
empowerment of women therefore remains a priority
area of concern for the countries of the region. |
INTRODUCTION
1. The
goal of achieving the economic and social empowerment of women
is enshrined in the Nairobi Forward-looking Strategies for the
Advancement of Women (1985), the Jakarta Declaration for the
Advancement of Women in Asia and the Pacific (1994), and the
Beijing Declaration and the Platform for Action (1995). These
landmark declarations heralded a new beginning in the region's
determination to achieve the economic, social and political
emancipation of women and galvanized national action as well as
leading to regional cooperation in achieving the economic and
social empowerment of women.
2. As a
consequence, the empowerment of women constitutes one of the
fundamental objectives of all the development efforts of almost
all countries in the region. The integration of the region's
trade, investment and financial ties with the world economy has
altered the economic and social roles of women as business
owners, entrepreneurs, managers, workers and family support
providers. The continuing growth of the service sector and the
declining importance of physical capital in the production
process are also bringing new opportunities for women to improve
their economic and social status. The activities of women's
organizations and networks have contributed significantly in
raising consciousness about the need for the economic and social
empowerment of women.
3. There
are also formidable challenges. The progress so far achieved in
empowering women is highly uneven, with the weaker economies,
especially the least developed countries and the economies in
transition, falling significantly behind. The present economic
turmoil has exposed women to greater uncertainty. They are now
experiencing the major brunt of the crisis and the adjustment
process in the form of increased unemployment. Poverty remains
the single most debilitating factor, hampering the integration
of women into the development process. In many countries, the
number of women in poverty continues to grow, with renewed fear
that the present economic crisis in the region is likely to push
a large number of women into poverty and social despair.
Trafficking in women and children, with all its attendant social
ills, and violence against women, have remained a major cause
for concern in the region. The problems of economic and social
support for ageing populations, especially older women, loom as
an emerging challenge. Women are still grossly under-represented
in the decision-making process and have restricted access to
productive resources and social support systems.
I. ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL EMPOWERMENT OF WOMEN:
SOME RECENT TRENDS
4. Since
the beginning of this decade, much has been achieved in
empowering women in the economic and social fields. An
increasing volume of development financial resources has been
devoted to achieving that objective. Consequently, many
countries of the region have been able to report increased
female literacy and enrolment rates, improved gender equality in
education, reduced infant and child mortality rates, declining
maternal mortality rates and expanding access to reproductive
health services. The participation of women in formal economic
activities has also registered a noticeable improvement.
A. Growing economic participation
5.
Economic empowerment constitutes one of the fundamental building
blocks in efforts towards the overall empowerment of women.
Participation in formal economic activities on terms and
conditions which reflect the productive capacity of women, and
their control over their own incomes, are some of the important
dimensions of economic empowerment. In that context, the
increase in economic participation has been the most significant
change for women throughout the region during the last two
decades. This is reflected in the growing labour-force
participation rates across all the countries in the region for
the period 1980-1996 (table 1). Although the increasing work
participation of women has been viewed as part of the general
employment boom created by the export-led economic expansion,
female labour-force participation rates have tended to increase
more than those for men in the Asian and Pacific region,
suggesting that women's economic participation has been a
critical feature of the region's quest for the economic
empowerment of women.
6. There
are significant differences within the region, indicating that
the progress on this front has been highly uneven. Table 1 shows
that the East and South-East Asian countries achieved
substantially higher rates of female labour-force participation
than South Asian countries (except Sri Lanka). But the
differences are even greater than indicated by the available
data, for in South Asia (and especially in Bangladesh and India)
a notable part of the increase in participation rates has been
due to the greater recognition of women's work in national
census and sample surveys.
7. It is
now widely appreciated that the Asian economic dynamism was
fuelled by the productive contributions of Asian women: in the
form of paid labour in export-related activities and in
services, through the remittances sent by migrant women workers,
and through the vast amounts of unpaid labour of women as
liberalization and government fiscal contraction transferred
many areas of public provision of goods and services to
households and to women within households. The female share of
total employment by sector in a number of Asian countries is
quite high, particularly in China, Indonesia, Malaysia, the
Philippines, the Republic of Korea, Sri Lanka and Thailand.
Export-oriented production for the world market and the ability
to preserve competitiveness in such production over an extended
period of time appear to be crucial in explaining women's high
share in total employment.
Table 1.
Labour force structure and trends
|
|
Growth rate
(percentage) |
Labour-force
participation rate |
|
|
|
Male |
Female |
|
|
1980-1996 |
1980 |
1996 |
1980 |
1996 |
|
|
East and North-East
Asia |
|
|
China |
1.9 |
60.6 |
63.7 |
48.9 |
55.6 |
|
|
Hong Kong |
1.6 |
62.2 |
63.6 |
35.2 |
39.6 |
|
|
Mongolia |
2.9 |
50.3 |
51.6 |
42.5 |
45.5 |
|
|
Republic of Korea |
2.3 |
49.5 |
58.3 |
31.9 |
40.4 |
|
|
South-East Asia |
|
|
Brunei Darussalam |
4.0 |
51.8 |
54.7 |
18.0 |
31.5 |
|
|
Cambodia |
2.6 |
52.1 |
51.4 |
55.7 |
52.3 |
|
|
Indonesia |
2.9 |
51.5 |
56.2 |
27.2 |
37.2 |
|
|
Lao People's Democratic Republic |
2.4 |
56.1 |
51.8 |
47.1 |
44.8 |
|
|
Malaysia |
2.8 |
50.7 |
50.2 |
26.1 |
30.1 |
|
|
Myanmar |
2.2 |
57.0 |
59.6 |
44.3 |
45.5 |
|
|
Philippines |
2.6 |
50.6 |
51.4 |
27.4 |
31.1 |
|
|
Singapore |
2.7 |
57.3 |
61.2 |
32.7 |
39.6 |
|
|
Thailand |
2.7 |
54.8 |
63.8 |
49.5 |
55.2 |
|
|
Viet Nam |
4.6 |
51.1 |
52.5 |
44.5 |
49.4 |
|
|
South and South-West
Asia |
|
|
Bangladesh |
2.4 |
52.7 |
56.6 |
41.2 |
43.5 |
|
|
Bhutan |
1.8 |
61.9 |
58.4 |
40.9 |
38.9 |
|
|
India |
2.0 |
55.8 |
57.4 |
30.5 |
28.6 |
|
|
Iran (Islamic Republic of) |
3.7 |
47.0 |
44.4 |
12.4 |
15.2 |
|
|
Nepal |
2.3 |
57.9 |
54.4 |
38.5 |
37.8 |
|
|
Pakistan |
3.4 |
52.2 |
51.8 |
16.9 |
20.3 |
|
|
Sri Lanka |
2.8 |
52.8 |
54.6 |
20.2 |
30.1 |
|
|
Turkey |
2.5 |
53.6 |
58.2 |
30.4 |
34.1 |
|
Source:
International Labour Organization,
World Labour Report, 1997-98
(Geneva, 1997).
8.
Gender-based wage differentials have been decreasing in several
countries of the region, thereby contributing towards more
gender equality in the economic field. Available evidence
suggests that female wages as a proportion of male wages in
manufacturing have been going up (see figure). Thus, in the
decade between 1987 and 1996, some decline in gender-based wage
differentials is evident for Malaysia, the Republic of Korea,
Singapore and Thailand.
9. The
growing participation of women in paid employment has
contributed significantly to the economic and social empowerment
of women. Access to earned income improves women's position
within the household substantially, gives them greater control
over the distribution of such earnings and household resources,
and generally improves their status and strength in society as
well as their own self-esteem. The ability to earn income from
outside and to engage in activities other than
household-oriented ones can lead to significant social change in
the long run. Where women are generally denied the ownership of
property and control over assets, the ability to earn outside
income can become an important instrument for the transformation
of gender relations and challenge many traditional modes of
social and economic relations. Growth in employment has also led
to bridging the gender wage gap, suggesting that there can be
macroeconomic effects on the conditions and pay of women workers
independent of any policy interventions. However, under the
present circumstances, there could be several difficulties with
relying on this process to reduce gender gaps in employment. The
excess demand for labour that was being experienced in some of
the countries in the region is likely to disappear and current
trends indicate increased female unemployment, implying that
gender-based wage differentials could increase.
10. Small
businesses have emerged as significant avenues for the economic
empowerment of women. The flexible nature of these businesses
facilitates the participation of women in formal economic
activities as entrepreneurs, managers and workers. They can be
run with simple technology, and limited financial and managerial
resources and often serve local markets, characteristics which
favour women's participation in gainful activities. They also
tend to be family-based, an important aspect in women's
decisions to participate in formal economic activities. However,
the effective participation of women in these businesses is
highly constrained by their limited access to financial
resources, marketing links, technology, business networks, and
information on investment opportunities. They also face legal
and regulatory obstacles in many countries of the region.
Effective policies and programmes are needed in these areas to
promote the participation of women in small businesses.
B. Improvements in social development indicators
11. There
has been a gradual improvement in the social empowerment of
women, although the base of gender inequality has been so strong
that it continues to dominate the outcome (table 2). Thus, Asia
is the only region in the world where the sex ratio (women per
thousand men) continues
Figure.
Trends in female wages as a percentage of male wages in selected
countries and areas of the Asian and Pacific region

Source:
Calculated from International Labour Organization,
Yearbook of Labour Statistics,
1998 (Geneva, 1998).
Table 2.
Some social development indicators in selected countries and
areas of the Asian and Pacific region
|
|
Sex ratio |
Fertility rate
(prcentage growth) |
Female life expectancy
rate (years) |
Female adult literacy
rate
(percentage) |
|
|
1975 |
1992 |
1975-1980 |
1990-1995 |
1980-1993 |
1995 |
|
East and North-East
Asia |
|
|
China |
943 |
944 |
2.9 |
2.2 |
64.0 |
73.0 |
72.7 |
|
|
Hong Kong |
955 |
938 |
2.3 |
1.4 |
77.9 |
81.0 |
88.0 |
|
|
Republic of Korea |
985 |
981 |
2.8 |
1.8 |
- |
- |
96.7 |
|
|
South-East Asia |
|
|
Indonesia |
1 016 |
1 007 |
4.7 |
3.1 |
55.2 |
65.2 |
78.0 |
|
|
Malaysia |
987 |
983 |
4.2 |
3.6 |
66.9 |
73.0 |
78.1 |
|
|
Myanmar |
999 |
1 009 |
5.0 |
4.2 |
54.0 |
60.0 |
77.7 |
|
|
Philippines |
983 |
972 |
5.0 |
3.9 |
63.4 |
67.0 |
94.3 |
|
|
Singapore |
957 |
907 |
1.9 |
1.7 |
74.7 |
78.0 |
86.3 |
|
|
Thailand |
1 008 |
1 019 |
4.3 |
2.2 |
63.0 |
71.0 |
91.6 |
|
|
Viet Nam |
1 054 |
1 038 |
5.6 |
3.9 |
63.0 |
67.0 |
91.2 |
|
|
South and South-West
Asia |
|
|
Bangladesh |
937 |
943 |
6.7 |
4.7 |
57.1 |
55.0 |
26.1 |
|
|
India |
931 |
936 |
4.8 |
3.9 |
54.7 |
61.0 |
37.7 |
|
|
Pakistan |
931 |
921 |
7.0 |
6.2 |
50.0 |
59.0 |
24.4 |
|
|
Sri Lanka |
936 |
998 |
3.8 |
2.5 |
66.0 |
74.0 |
87.2 |
|
Sources:
ESCAP, Statistical
Compendium on Women in Asia and the Pacific
(ST/ESCAP/1454);
United
Nations Development Programme,
Human Development Report 1998
(New York, 1998).
to be
adverse to women. In some cases, the sex ratio has actually
worsened in the recent past. Thus, in several countries in the
region from South Asia (India and Pakistan) to East Asia (China
and the Republic of Korea), sex ratios declined between 1975 and
1992. Life expectancy rates for women show an increase in most
of Asia, and both the improvements and the absolute levels in
this variable are better for the East and South-East Asian
region than in the case of South Asia (with the exception of Sri
Lanka).
12.
Fertility rates have declined in the region, even though the
total fertility rate and the average number of children per
woman remain high (over four) in several countries in the
region. The fertility rates on average remain high in those
countries of Asia where female literacy is low and opportunities
for outside work participation are limited. It is therefore
increasingly accepted that, in addition to reflecting general
conditions of economic growth and the availability of both
health care and birth control facilities, fertility rates also
serve as a proxy for women's general empowerment. This is
because these rates are closely linked to the literacy and
educational status of women, age at marriage, and other
important features of women's status.
13. In
terms of literacy rates, gender gaps across Asia appear to be
narrowing, although the rate of change is still slow in several
countries. There are also subregional variations, with
Bangladesh, India and Pakistan in South Asia falling far behind
East and South-East Asia in terms of adult female literacy
rates. Sri Lanka bears some resemblance to the South-East Asian
pattern. The changes in adult female literacy rates tend to be
closely correlated with the outside work participation of women.
Efforts to reduce gender inequality in education can therefore
affect the paid employment of women with the greater likelihood
of households investing more in the education of girls.
C. Access to technology, including information technology
14.
Promoting access to productive resources and social support
systems constitutes one of the fundamental building blocks in
efforts to empower women in the region. Access to productive
resources such as credit, technology, infrastructure, marketing
links and networking facilities can significantly enlarge
opportunities for women to engage in formal economic activities
and improve their social status. In that regard, promoting
access to new and emerging technologies, including information
and communication technology, has become a powerful tool for
women's empowerment.
15. The
Beijing Platform for Action strongly endorses women's use of
computer networking for the dissemination of information and
networking in order to increase women's role in decision-making
and their part in the democratic process. According to the
Platform, the Internet could be a powerful tool for women to use
in disseminating and exchanging information, as well as in
gathering information. For example, Web sites could provide
information on subjects such as women's studies, gender,
feminism, women's health, and women in computer science,
engineering, academia and industry.
16.
However, the Beijing Platform for Action also notes that most
women, especially those in developing countries, cannot afford
to "travel" the information highway (Internet) and thus are
unable to use it to access information or network with others.
To remedy this situation, and strengthen women's participation
in society, the Platform calls on organizations at all levels to
assist in increasing opportunities for women to use computers
and the Internet. Along with access, the Platform further
identifies training and network development as crucial.
17.
Electronic communication has increased women's productivity,
given them more balanced information than the regular news
media, enriched their understanding of global issues, and
enabled them to meet people with similar interests and share
information. Along with extolling the benefits women can reap
when they go on line, an ESCAP survey showed that women continue
to face barriers in using the information superhighway. These
include lack of training, the high cost of equipment and, in
some places, the high cost of being connected.
18.
Obstacles to Internet use include lack of Internet-capable
computers, language barriers, lack of expertise and lack of
training opportunities. The ESCAP survey found that, as a rule,
women's organizations in the region continue to distribute
information through traditional channels - mail, fax/telephone,
and/or person-to-person. While a few groups are using the
Internet to find information, they do not use it for
distribution. Also, Internet use by many organizations is
restricted to E-mail because their older computers are not
capable of other Internet functions.
19. To
overcome the psychological barriers which inhibit women's use of
information technology, training is seen as critical.
Unfortunately, training programmes and materials are often not
gender and/or culturally sensitive, training is expensive and it
is often offered at the wrong time of day for women. To promote
women's use of the information highway, training must cover
basic skills such as computer operations and how to search for
information, as well as the creation and maintenance of
electronic information systems, and setting up Web sites and
computer conferences. Ongoing user support and monitoring are
also critical.
D. Mainstreaming gender concerns through national mechanisms and
promoting greaterparticipation in community-based and
non-governmental organizations
20.
Strengthening national mechanisms and promoting the greater
participation of women in community-based and non-governmental
organizations remain one of the major objectives in empowering
women. In that regard, national machineries have emerged as
important institutional systems for the advancement of women,
with focal points as their primary components. International
Women's Year (1975) and the United Nations Decade for Women
(1976-1985), stimulated the establishment of national machinery
in most countries, but 30 per cent of Asian and Pacific
countries established focal points in 1985 and thereafter, with
up to 40 per cent of them functioning without either mandates or
vested authority. Decisions about structures and functions of
machinery may either limit or enhance their potential for
mainstreaming the advancement of women.
21. While
the positioning of national focal points varies widely, Asian
and Pacific countries use four major structures: (a) women's
organizations; (b) women's commissions, councils or committees
attached to the Prime Minister, President, Governor or Cabinet
of Ministers; (c) women's ministries; and (d) women's units
within one or more ministries. The majority of countries use the
first three structures, whereby the focal point can access high
levels of power and influence national decision-making. The
remaining two fifths limit this access and influence to units in
ministries.
22. During
the last decade, many countries introduced major changes in the
location of their focal points. Elsewhere, movement took place
within ministries, and many focal points were relocated more
than once. As a result, during the decade, women's units were
incorporated in ministries simultaneously assuming
responsibility in different substantive areas. These include
social welfare, children's affairs, youth, sports, family
planning, human resources development, community affairs,
culture, justice, relief, resettlement, education, science,
technology, archives, religion, teaching hospitals, interior
affairs, political affairs, health, transport, the environment,
population, labour, national unity and, finally, social
development.
23.
National machineries are becoming increasingly complex as
governments supplement and complement focal points. Nearly 20
countries complement their focal points with subnational units
at provincial, district or even village level. Women's studies
programmes and research units are increasingly becoming major
components of national machinery. Other integrative mechanisms
link focal points among ministries and with communities of women
and their organizations.
24. In
addition, mechanisms organize input from concerned
organizations, while others provide forums for dialogue and
negotiation. Some even enable governments to access researchers
and to elicit their substantive direction for the preparation of
reviews and evaluations and the design of policies and
programmes. Governments assign a range of functions to focal
points, but four major functions are essential to mainstreaming:
(a) research and policy analysis and identifying issues and
concerns; (b) recommendations and advice; (c) implementation;
and (d) monitoring and evaluation.
25.
National mechanisms support mainstreaming at the highest level
of national decision-making. They also create enabling
environments for focal point staff to combine research and
statistics with programme and project experience to furnish a
solid foundation for recommendations to a predominantly male
audience. But in many countries, skilled personnel are not
available in sufficient numbers from within the civil service or
as cadres of women's organizations to furnish such
recommendations. While some governments introduce training to
enhance the analytic capacity and gender sensitivity of their
staff, it offers insufficient support for the effective
operation of national machinery. For this reason, governments
often establish new components with mandates for policy-oriented
research and monitoring functions.
26.
Dissemination of information forms another priority area of
concern in strengthening national mechanisms. While several
governments organized information centres during the last
decade, these remain inadequate and often lack staff with
sufficient training to use what is available effectively. Focal
point initiatives on behalf of women are severely curtailed by
inadequate information, especially accurate and timely data and
policy-oriented research.
27. The
advancement of women in development in the region entails the
creation of an enabling environment. Focal points ought to be
given mandated authority with primary responsibility for women.
They should also be complemented with mechanisms that lend them
assistance and access to power, information and support. Such an
environment remains a prerequisite for women and men to work
together towards empowering women.
28.
Women's groups, NGOs and other sections of the civil society are
also playing a vital role in empowering women in the region.
Women's organizations have greatly helped in raising
consciousness about the rights of women and drawn attention to
the social and economic hardships experienced by them. These
organizations, along with the relevant NGOs, have been
campaigning for legal reforms and legislative changes for the
betterment of women. Social development in general and human
rights in particular form the broad frameworks within which the
women's organizations are working in advancing the cause of
women. As in most other areas, these organizations tend to be
more resourceful and effective in the developed and more
advanced countries of the region. In the weaker economies, these
organizations need further strengthening in order for them to
play a more meaningful role in empowering women.
II. SOME CRITICAL CHALLENGES
A. Asian economic crisis and the need for a social safety net
29. The
ongoing economic crisis in several countries of the region has
underlined the vulnerable situation of women. It has also
severely undermined the progress made during the last decade in
empowering women in the economic and social fields. Shutdowns
and lay-offs in the manufacturing sector have affected many
women, who have borne the major brunt of job losses in the
affected countries. In all of these economies, female employment
in the service sector is also being negatively affected, with
older women workers the first to be laid off. Since the affected
sectors are also the ones which had been employing more women,
the rapid feminization of employment in many of these previously
high-growth economies could be followed in the next phase of
crisis and adjustment by the equally rapid feminization of
growing unemployment. The economic crisis is also causing male
unemployment. This growing male unemployment is affecting women
directly, and an increasing number are being pushed into the
labour market and accepting previously unacceptable work
conditions owing to the pressure of declining real household
incomes.
30. The
current process of adjustment in much of the region is likely to
have other far-reaching consequences for women, including loss
of other sources of income within the household as the
deflationary policies imposed on several countries of the region
begin to take hold. It is now generally admitted that this
deflationary package is leading to substantial fiscal
compression as well as absolute declines in economic activity in
several important subsectors.
31. The
issue of large-scale unemployment is especially serious in the
region as no developing country, except the Republic of Korea,
has significant safety nets in the form of unemployment benefits
or insurance for the unemployed. The newly unemployed throughout
the region are forced to turn to traditional sources, such as
the family. But family incomes have declined as all workers'
incomes are being substantially squeezed.
32. In
addition, the current deflationary adjustment policies will
affect women adversely, not only as workers, but as household
providers, mothers etc. Women's access to basic needs such as
food, clothing and shelter, and to the provisioning of common
property resources, could be curtailed. Their access to
education and skill formation that allows them to move out of
low-productivity jobs could also diminish. There are also
serious implications for total household incomes in different
sectors and gender-based distribution within households. As
austerity measures begin to take hold, women could be required
to spend more time on caring for the young and infirm as
health-care facilities and other social services are reduced.
33. In
addition, where many women have been forced in such
circumstances to seek additional income outside the home, this
has put pressure on girl children, who have to take up some of
the activities of the household and child care otherwise
performed by their mothers. In extreme cases, this has led to
their withdrawal from schooling and other negative effects.
Other negative features which have a gender dimension associated
with structural adjustment programmes are in the area of food
security - a critical issue throughout South Asia, China and
Indonesia, as well as other parts of the region. The emphasis on
primary product export, along with cuts in food and other
subsidies typical of such structural packages, lead almost
axiomatically to increases in the relative price of food and
therefore put pressure on real consumption within households. It
is widely acknowledged that in many Asian societies, especially
South Asia, social and cultural norms are such that women and
girl children face disproportionately excessive cuts in their
food consumption when household per capita access to food
declines. Where adjustment programmes have also tended to
include effective cuts in public distribution systems for food
and essential items, these place a special burden on females
within the family.
34. There
are also specific problems facing migrant women workers in the
wake of the present economic crisis. In some instances, migrant
workers could become the focus of local hostility with growing
job losses. Returning workers face the added burden of
re-establishing themselves economically and socially in their
home countries. Measures such as forcible repatriation can
become a problem if urgent measures are not adopted to safeguard
the interests of the migrant workers.
B. Empowering women in poverty
35.
Significant progress has been achieved in alleviating the worst
forms of poverty in many countries of the region through
sustained economic growth supported by active and well-targeted
public policy. However, the Asian and Pacific region remains
home to the largest segment of the world population who live in
abject poverty. Progress in poverty alleviation also seems to be
uneven, with many countries falling far behind. Of the poor,
women constitute the majority, with the number of rural women in
poverty rising over the last 20 years by about 50 per cent
compared with an increase of about 25 per cent for rural men.
Recent studies also indicate that the proportion of
female-headed households has been increasing and a
disproportionate number of those households are among the very
poor. In the context of this, the importance of poverty
reduction as a tool to empower women in poverty has been widely
recognized. The Jakarta Plan of Action accorded highest priority
to combating the "growing feminization of poverty". Similarly,
the Beijing Platform for Action identified the "persistent and
increasing burden of poverty of women" as one of the 12 critical
areas of concern.
36. One of
the recent innovations in empowering women in poverty has been
the increasing emphasis on microcredit programmes and schemes.
These have become highly significant in empowering women in
poverty through the mobilization of asset-less women to engage
in self-employment and income-generating activities. Microcredit
schemes have, in many instances, demonstrated that the poor
women are bankable and a valuable source for savings
mobilization. Apart from the economic impacts, access to
microcredit has had far-reaching social consequences for women
in poverty. It has given rise to a new division of
responsibilities within the borrowing families, with a greater
recognition of women as significant contributors to family
welfare. It has also improved the social status of women
borrowers and attenuated the grip of patriarchy in traditional
societies. However, these benefits and potentials of microcredit
programmes and schemes have not been uniformly realized in all
the developing countries of the region. Important issues have
remained unanswered, with the growing realization that not all
microcredit programmes and schemes are succeeding in
incorporating gender issues effectively to promote the social
and economic empowerment of women in poverty.
37. The
importance of poverty reduction as a goal to empower women has
been widely recognized. However, in spite of the preponderance
of the poor being female and the increasing feminization of
poverty, anti-poverty interventions have tended to be
gender-blind, or at best gender-neutral, in needs
identification, project design and implementation. Most
countries lack a coherent, balanced agenda for combating female
poverty. It is therefore important that poverty reduction
strategies be approached from a gender perspective and that the
underlying causes of female poverty be addressed and measures to
empower women to combat poverty be undertaken.
C. Promotion of women's rights as human rights
38. The
promotion of women's rights as human rights was one of the main
objectives of the Beijing Platform for Action. In that context,
ratification and implementation of the Convention on the
Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women has
become an important instrument in empowering women in the
region. As of January 1999, the Convention had been ratified by
over two thirds of ESCAP members and associate members. Of
those, nearly one third have entered reservations for reasons of
religion, culture and conflict of law. Such reservations and/or
declarations effectively dilute the human rights standards set
by the Convention for women in those countries and also for the
region. Even where ratification has been without reservation,
implementation has been slow in a number of countries, thereby
allowing existing discriminatory practices against women to
continue under the sanction of religious principles or cultural
and customary values. Given the differences and the degree of
sensitivities posed by the cultural and religious
particularities of individual countries of subregions, a
rights-based approach to gender equality may provide some common
ground which can yield positive results.
39. In
recent years, trafficking in women has attracted a great deal of
attention. It is now widely seen as one of the worst forms of
the violation of women's rights as human rights. It has become a
serious problem without borders, affecting countries within Asia
as well as other parts of the world. Women have been trafficked
for prostitution and other forms of sexual exploitation such as
sex tourism and pornography, domestic workers, labourers in
sweatshops and on construction sites, as beggars and brides. The
increasing use of new information technologies, in particular,
the Internet, presents a new dimension to the problem faced.
Poverty and economic deprivation have also subjected women to
trafficking. In many instances, trafficked women are becoming
victims of highly organized networks. Women victims in these
situations lack legal protection and legal rights. Although
reporting on the problem has increased, it is unclear whether
this is a reflection of a growing problem or whether it is the
result of increased attention to the problem at the national,
regional and international levels. Quantitative estimates of the
dimensions of the problem are not available as there are almost
no reliable estimates, although many countries are beginning to
compile information on the problem. The General Assembly, in its
resolution 52/98 of 12 December 1997, emphasized the need for
more concerted and sustained national, regional and
international action over the alarming levels of trafficking in
women and girls.
40. In
terms of the regional response to the crisis to date, the draft
South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC)
convention on preventing and combating trafficking in women and
children for prostitution is scheduled to be signed by SAARC
member States in 1999. The draft convention seeks to promote
cooperation amongst SAARC member States to deal effectively with
the various aspects of prevention, interdiction and suppression
of trafficking in women and children; as well as the
repatriation and rehabilitation of victims of trafficking; and
prevent the use of women and children in international
prostitution networks, particularly where the countries of the
SAARC region are countries of origin, transit and destination.
The positive response by SAARC States demonstrates that there is
political readiness to realize joint action to suppress
trafficking in the subregion.
41. It is
widely hoped that the SAARC model can be replicated regionwide.
The experiences of the SAARC countries as well as the experience
in drafting the Hague Ministerial Declaration on European
Guidelines for Effective Measures to Prevent and Combat
Trafficking in Women for the Purpose of Sexual Exploitation in
April 1997 could be reviewed carefully to identify the common
denominators in the development of a regionwide response to
combat trafficking in women. The adoption of the Bangkok Accord
and Plan of Action to Combat Trafficking in Women at a Regional
Conference on Trafficking in Women, held at Bangkok in November
1998 (see para. 47 below), provided the first step forward in
harnessing a regional response to the problem.
42.
Violence against women constitutes another form of gross
violation of women's rights as human rights. It has become a
grave social problem, requiring urgent attention. Although the
problem in the region is not new, it has so far attracted
limited social recognition and legal redress owing to the
complexities of patriarchal values, traditions, norms and
standards. Even laws often discriminate against women and
offenders go unpunished. Violence against women takes a variety
of forms, including physical, mental and sexual abuse. While
many countries in the region are engaged in combating violence
against women in cooperation with NGOs and women's
organizations, there is a need for more cooperation at the
regional and subregional levels, particularly in those areas
which affect women from several countries.
D. Coping with ageing populations
43. As
ageing in general becomes a major issue with serious social and
economic consequences, the emerging challenge of a growing
number of ageing women needs to be recognized. Several countries
would find it difficult to cope with these consequences.
Declines in fertility rates along with declines in mortality
rates and increases in life expectancy have created conditions
in which the region's population can be expected to age rapidly.
Sex differentials in mortality imply that the number of older
women will be higher than that of older men. Ageing women are
increasingly finding themselves having to depend on their
children and other relatives for economic survival and social
support. But with the declining importance of extended families
and the absence of social safety nets, an increasing number of
older women will find themselves without any economic and social
support. Appropriately designed policies and systems are needed
to cope with this important emerging challenge.
E. Promoting greater participation in the decision-making
process
44.
Promoting the greater participation of women in the
decision-making process remains another major objective in
several countries of the region towards the goal of empowering
women. Awareness of the need for promoting the greater
participation of women in the decision-making process is on the
rise. In several countries of the region, women have reached the
highest positions of political authority. Parliamentary
representation is also on the rise in several countries. Yet,
women by and large still find themselves excluded from the state
or government apparatus in many countries of the region.
Regional experience suggests that women tend to do better in
terms of participation in the decision-making process when
proactive policies are in place, backed up by a social consensus
on the need for empowering women.
III. ESCAP INITIATIVES IN EMPOWERING WOMEN IN THE ECONOMIC AND
SOCIAL FIELDS
Empowering women in poverty
45. ESCAP
accords high priority to empowering women in poverty. Following
the completion of the project on improving the status of women
in poverty in April 1997, a second project on empowering women
in poverty was initiated, with the objective of formulating
economic and social policies, including devising social safety
nets and economic empowerment schemes, to address the issue of
feminization of poverty. Under this project, a regional seminar
is scheduled to be held at Dhaka in July 1999; twenty-two
countries are expected to attend the seminar. An innovative
employment promotion methodology is being tested to assist
unemployed women with no income-earning skills to acquire the
necessary skills. This methodology, called
"success-case-replication", uses local villages with successful
enterprises to train the unemployed women in the same or nearby
communities. The methodology is very low-cost and has generated
an income of about 20 dollars for the participants for each
dollar of investment. Bhutan, the Lao People's Democratic
Republic, Mongolia, Nepal, Philippines, Sri Lanka, Thailand and
Viet Nam are participating in this project. Another activity has
focused on strengthening income-generating opportunities for
rural women in Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan
and Uzbekistan. Under this project, studies have been prepared
in the participating countries which would be discussed at an
expert group meeting scheduled to be held in Kazakhstan in 1999.
Education and training of women
46. A
project on technology exchange for food processing and
establishment of a database on grass-roots organizations to
strengthen women entrepreneurs was completed in 1998. It has
provided hands-on, practical training and exposure in the area
of low-cost and appropriate technologies in the food processing
sector to over 130 NGO-associated women and men. ESCAP is
currently implementing two projects to promote literacy for
women in 3 subregions and 10 countries in the region. The
project in South Asia, involving Bangladesh, India, Nepal and
Pakistan, focuses on post-literacy programme development. The
project in South-East Asia and the Pacific, involving Bhutan,
Cambodia, Lao People's Democratic Republic, Papua New Guinea,
Solomon Islands and Vanuatu, focuses on the capacity-building of
local organizations engaged in literacy training for women. The
subregional workshop held for South Asia developed a handbook on
post-literacy programmes for women's empowerment in South Asia.
The handbook was introduced to the four participating countries
through national workshops and field-tested through pilot
projects in 1998. The handbook will be finalized at the
subregional evaluation workshop, to be convened early in 1999.
Under the project for South-East Asia and the Pacific, pilot
projects have been implemented in 1998 as a follow-up of the
training courses conducted in 1997.
Violence against women
47.
Government and non-government representatives from 14 countries
of the region adopted the Bangkok Accord and Plan of Action to
Combat Trafficking in Women at a two-day Regional Conference on
Trafficking in Women, held at Bangkok in November 1998. The
Conference was organized by ESCAP in collaboration with ILO, the
International Organization for Migration, the National
Commission on Women's Affairs of Thailand and the Asian Women's
Fund. The Bangkok Accord and Plan of Action represents regional
consensus on joint action needed at the national, subregional
and regional levels to tackle trafficking in women. The adopted
Plan of Action is divided into two parts, actions at the
national level and those at the subregional, regional and
multilateral levels. At the national level, comprehensive
guidelines for action are provided in the important areas of
prevention, protection and humanitarian treatment of victims,
repatriation and reintegration, sanctions against traffickers,
medical and psychological intervention, information and
monitoring mechanisms and participation of concerned parties. At
the other levels, provisions include the creation of subregional
and bilateral treaties to set up frameworks for action, the
promotion of more collaboration, coordination and cooperation
among international agencies to maximize existing resources by
avoiding duplication of activities and approaching the issue
from new dimensions and perspectives, such as promotion of human
security and combating and preventing organized crime.
Women
and the economy
48. The
second phase of a project on the promotion of women's
participation in economic development in Indochina was
implemented through the organization of a subregional workshop
on promoting women in small business, held at Ho Chi Minh City,
Viet Nam, in October 1998. In this second phase, the workshop
aimed at developing measures to promote women in small
businesses by equipping them to undertake self-employment and
operate their businesses more effectively in three Indochinese
countries, Cambodia, the Lao People's Democratic Republic and
Viet Nam. Representatives of governments, chambers of commerce,
small enterprise promotion centres, Viet Nam based international
organizations and women-related organizations attended the
workshop and adopted the Ho Chi Minh Plan of Action for
Promoting Women in Small Businesses. The Plan of Action called
for concrete action in areas such as credit for small
businesses, marketing, technology, networking, and reform of the
legal and regulatory framework.
49. A
regional meeting on the impact of globalization on women was
convened at Bangkok in June 1998. The meeting discussed the key
issues and concerns facing women in a period of rapid
globalization and analysed the effects of the Asian economic
crisis on women. The meeting led to exchange of information on
the needs of women as workers, home providers and care-givers
during periods of boom and economic recession. The meeting also
made important recommendations for consideration by policy
makers and NGOs in formulating national recovery efforts to
stabilize all sectors of the affected community.
Human
rights of women
50. A
subregional workshop on eliminating violence against women was
held at Dhaka in December 1997 as part of phase two of the
project on promotion of women's rights as human rights focused
on violence against women (phase II). Fifteen experts from
governments and NGOs from six countries in South Asia
participated in reviewing gender discriminatory laws as they
related to women in the context of violence against women and
trafficking in women and girls. The project aimed at assisting
policy makers and NGOs in their consciousness-raising activities
on violations of women's human rights, with special emphasis on
physical and psychological violence against women. Activities
included the documentation of successful practices in the
prevention and elimination of violence against women in the
subregion and proposed recommendations to governments, NGOs and
international organizations in increasing awareness about many
forms of violence against women, acceleration of the formulation
of laws on the elimination of violence against women, revision
of gender discriminatory laws and strengthening networking among
governments and NGOs working in this area.
51. A
project on the promotion of the Convention of the Elimination of
All Forms of Discrimination against Women through women in
development NGO-networks in the Pacific is being implemented to
facilitate the promotion of the Convention in the four Pacific
island countries which have ratified it: Fiji, Papua New Guinea,
Samoa and Vanuatu. At this stage, national workshops are being
conducted following the identification of national NGOs in the
four countries. Efforts will be made to integrate the promotion
of the Convention into existing regular programmes of NGOs and
government agencies. The activities of the project will be
reviewed at a subregional meeting of Pacific NGOs in 1999.
52. ESCAP
also participated in a consultative meeting on the
implementation of Convention mechanisms in the Pacific, held at
Nadi, Fiji in July 1998. This activity was organized jointly by
SPC, the United Nations Development Programme and ESCAP. The
meeting provided an opportunity for exchange of information on
the implementation of the Convention between the countries that
have ratified the instrument, those countries planning
ratification in the near future, and those contemplating
ratification.
Data
and information networking
53.
Activities under the Women's Information Network for Asia and
the Pacific (WINAP) network for regional information exchange
continued through the publication of the
WINAP Newsletter on
gender-related regional programmes and activities on the WID
Internet Homepage (created in 1997 as part of WINAP activities)
and the WINAP Newsletter,
which has been continuously published on a semi-annual basis.
54. Under
the project on improving statistics on women in the ESCAP
region, 14 country profiles on women were released in 1998,
covering Bangladesh, China, Fiji, India, Indonesia, Iran
(Islamic Republic of), Nepal, Pakistan, Philippines, Samoa,
Solomon Islands, Sri Lanka, Thailand and Vanuatu. Two more
country profiles in the series are expected to be released in
early 1999, on Japan, and the Republic of Korea. As an output of
the activities under another project on statistics on gender
issues, six participating countries have published national
statistical booklets on women and men. These publications have
also been translated into national languages as part of the
activities of the project.
55. A
study, A Demographic
Perspective on Women in Development in Cambodia, Lao People's
Democratic Republic, Myanmar and Viet Nam, was
published in 1998 as part of the ESCAP Asian Population Studies
Series. The study contains a summary and interpretation of
recent demographic data and assesses the status of women in
development in those countries, highlighting similarities and
common patterns. The major findings of the study were presented
at a Policy Seminar on Gender Dimensions of Population and
Development in South-East Asia, held at Bangkok in September
1998.
56.
Activities planned by ESCAP include a project on safety nets for
women affected by the Asian financial crisis as one component of
an ESCAP umbrella programme of activities to evaluate the
socio-economic impacts of the economic crisis. The aim of the
project is to elaborate options and mechanisms that have been
tried and tested with a view to formulating regional guidance
for the consideration of policy makers. Another planned activity
involves a high-level meeting to review the implementation of
the Jakarta Declaration and the Plan of Action and the regional
implementation of the Beijing Declaration and Platform for
Action, which is scheduled to be held at Bangkok in October
1999. This meeting will assist the countries in the region in
conducting their own appraisal and assessment of the progress
achieved in the implementation of the Beijing Platform fo |