|
U.S. Public Health Service Task Force
Recommendations for Use--of Antiretroviral Drugs in Pregnant
HIV-1--Infected Women for Maternal Health and Interventions To
Reduce Perinatal HIV-1 Transmission in the United States*
Prepared by
Lynne M. Mofenson, M.D.
Center for Research for Mothers and Children
National Institute of Child Health and Human Development
National Institutes of Health
The material in this report originated in the National
Center for HIV, STD, and TB Prevention, Harold W. Jaffe, M.D.,
Director; Division of HIV/AIDS Prevention--Surveillance and
Epidemiology, Robert S. Janssen, M.D., Director.
Summary
These recommendations update the February 4, 2002,
guidelines developed by the Public Health Service for the use
of zidovudine (ZDV) to reduce the risk for perinatal human
immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) transmission. This
report provides health-care providers with information for
discussion with HIV-1--infected pregnant women to enable such
women to make an informed decision regarding the use of
antiretroviral drugs during pregnancy and use of elective
cesarean delivery to reduce perinatal HIV-1 transmission.
Various circumstances that commonly occur in clinical practice
are presented, and the factors influencing treatment
considerations are highlighted in this report. The Perinatal
HIV Guidelines Working Group recognizes that strategies to
prevent perinatal transmission and concepts related to
management of HIV disease in pregnant women are rapidly
evolving and will continually review new data and provide
regular updates to the guidelines. The most recent information
is available from the HIV/AIDS Treatment Information Service
(available at http://www.hivatis.org).
In February 1994, the results of Pediatric AIDS Clinical
Trials Group (PACTG) Protocol 076 documented that ZDV
chemoprophylaxis could reduce perinatal HIV-1 transmission by
nearly 70%. Epidemiologic data have since confirmed the
efficacy of ZDV for reduction of perinatal transmission and
have extended this efficacy to children of women with advanced
disease, low CD4+ T-lymphocyte counts, and prior
ZDV therapy. Additionally, substantial advances have been made
in the understanding of the pathogenesis of HIV-1 infection
and in the treatment and monitoring of persons with HIV-1
disease. These advances have resulted in changes in standard
antiretroviral therapy for HIV-1--infected adults. More
aggressive combination drug regimens that maximally suppress
viral replication are now recommended. Although considerations
associated with pregnancy may affect decisions regarding
timing and choice of therapy, pregnancy is not a reason to
defer standard therapy. Use of antiretroviral drugs in
pregnancy requires unique considerations, including the
possible need to alter dosage as a result of physiologic
changes associated with pregnancy, the potential for adverse
short- or long-term effects on the fetus and newborn, and the
effectiveness of the drugs in reducing the risk for perinatal
transmission. Data to address many of these considerations are
not yet available. Therefore, offering antiretroviral therapy
to HIV-1--infected women during pregnancy, whether primarily
for HIV-1 infection, for reduction of perinatal transmission,
or for both purposes, should be accompanied by a discussion of
the known and unknown short- and long-term benefits and risks
of such therapy to infected women and their infants. Standard
antiretroviral therapy should be discussed with and offered to
HIV-1--infected pregnant women. Additionally, to prevent
perinatal transmission, ZDV chemoprophylaxis should be
incorporated into the antiretroviral regimen.
Introduction
In February 1994, the Pediatric AIDS Clinical Trials Group
(PACTG) Protocol 076 demonstrated that a three-part--regimen
of zidovudine (ZDV) could reduce the risk for mother-to-child
human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1)--transmission by
nearly 70% (1). The regimen includes oral ZDV initiated
at 14--34 weeks' gestation and continued throughout pregnancy,
followed by intravenous ZDV during labor and oral
administration of ZDV to the infant for 6 weeks after delivery. In August 1994, a U.S. Public Health Service (USPHS)
task force issued recommendations for the use of ZDV for
reduction of perinatal HIV-1 transmission (),
and in July 1995, USPHS issued recommendations for universal
prenatal HIV-1 counseling and HIV-1 testing with consent for
all pregnant women in the United States ().
Since the publication of the results of PACTG 076,
epidemiologic--studies in the United States and France have
demonstrated dramatic decreases in perinatal transmission with
incorporation of the PACTG 076 ZDV regimen into general
clinical practice (4--9).
Since 1994, advances have been made in the understanding of
the pathogenesis of HIV-1 infection and in the treatment and
monitoring of HIV-1 disease. The rapidity and magnitude of
viral turnover during all stages of HIV-1 infection are
greater than previously recognized; plasma virions are
estimated to have a mean half-life of only 6 hours (10).
Thus, current therapeutic interventions focus on early
initiation of aggressive combination antiretroviral regimens
to maximally suppress viral replication, preserve immune
function, and reduce the development of resistance (11).
New, potent antiretroviral drugs that inhibit the protease
enzyme of HIV-1 are now available. When a protease inhibitor
is used in combination with nucleoside analog reverse
transcriptase inhibitors, plasma HIV-1 RNA levels can be
reduced for prolonged periods to levels that are undetectable
by current assays. Improved clinical outcome and survival have
been observed among adults receiving such regimens (12,13).
Additionally, viral load can now be more directly quantified
through assays that measure HIV-1 RNA copy number; these
assays have provided powerful new tools to assess disease
stage, risk for progression, and the--effects of therapy.
These advances have led to substantial changes in the standard
of treatment and monitoring for HIV-1--infected adults in the
United States.
Advances also have been made in the understanding of the
pathogenesis of perinatal HIV-1 transmission. Most perinatal
transmission likely occurs close to the time of or during
childbirth (15). Additional data that demonstrate the
short-term safety of the ZDV regimen are now available as a
result of follow-up of infants and women enrolled in PACTG
076; however, data from studies of animals concerning the
potential for transplacental carcinogenicity of ZDV affirm
the--need for long-term follow-up of children with
antiretroviral exposure in utero (16).
These advances have implications for maternal and fetal
health. Health-care providers considering the use of
antiretroviral agents for HIV-1--infected women during
pregnancy must take into account two separate but related
issues: 1) antiretroviral treatment of maternal HIV-1
infection, and 2) antiretroviral chemoprophylaxis to reduce
the risk for perinatal HIV-1 transmission. The benefits of
antiretroviral therapy for a pregnant woman must be weighed
against the risk of adverse events to the woman, fetus, and
newborn. Although ZDV chemoprophylaxis alone has substantially
reduced the risk for perinatal transmission, antiretroviral
monotherapy is now considered suboptimal for treatment of
HIV-1 infection, and combination drug regimens are considered
the standard of care for therapy .
This report reviews the special considerations regarding
use of antiretroviral drugs for pregnant women, updates
the--results of PACTG 076 and related clinical trials and
epidemiologic studies, discusses use of HIV-1 RNA and
antiretroviral drug resistance assays during pregnancy,
provides updated recommendations on antiretroviral
chemoprophylaxis for reducing perinatal transmission, and
provides recommendations related to use of elective cesarean
delivery as an intervention to reduce perinatal transmission.
These recommendations have been developed for use in the
United States. Although perinatal HIV-1 transmission occurs
worldwide, alternative strategies may be appropriate in other
countries. Policies and practices in other
countries--regarding the use of antiretroviral drugs for
reduction of perinatal HIV-1 transmission may differ from the
recommendations in this report and will depend on local
considerations, including availability and cost of ZDV, access
by pregnant women to facilities for safe intravenous infusions
during--labor, and alternative interventions being evaluated
in that area.
Background
Considerations Regarding Use of Antiretroviral Drugs by
HIV-1--infected Pregnant Women and Their Infants
Treatment recommendations for pregnant women infected with
HIV-1 have been based on the belief that therapies of known
benefit to women should not be withheld during pregnancy
unless there are known adverse effects on the mother, fetus,
or infant and unless these adverse effects outweigh the
benefit to the woman (17). Combination antiretroviral
therapy, usually consisting of two nucleoside analog reverse
transcriptase inhibitors and a protease inhibitor, is the
recommended standard treatment for HIV-1--infected adults who
are not pregnant ().
Pregnancy should not preclude the use of optimal therapeutic
regimens. However, recommendations regarding the choice of
antiretroviral drugs for treatment of infected pregnant women
are subject to unique considerations. These include possible
changes in dosing requirements resulting from physiologic
changes associated with pregnancy, potential--effects of
antiretroviral drugs on the pregnant woman, and the potential
short- and long-term effects of the antiretroviral drug on the
fetus and newborn, which may not be known for certain
antiretroviral drugs.
The decision to use any antiretroviral drug during
pregnancy should be made by the woman after discussing with
her health-care provider the known and unknown benefits and
risks to her and her fetus.
Physiologic changes that occur during pregnancy may--affect
the kinetics of drug absorption, distribution,
biotransformation, and elimination, thereby also affecting
requirements for drug dosing and potentially altering the
susceptibility of the pregnant woman to drug toxicity. During
pregnancy,--gastrointestinal transit time becomes prolonged;
body water and fat increase throughout gestation and are
accompanied by increases in cardiac output, ventilation, and
liver and renal blood flow; plasma protein concentrations
decrease; renal--sodium reabsorption increases; and changes
occur in metabolic enzyme pathways in the liver. Placental
transport of drugs, compartmentalization of drugs in the
embryo/fetus and placenta, biotransformation of drugs by the
fetus and placenta, and elimination of drugs by the fetus also
can affect drug pharmacokinetics in the pregnant woman.
Additional considerations regarding drug use in pregnancy are
the effects of the drug on the fetus and newborn, including
the potential for teratogenicity, mutagenicity, or
carcinogenicity, and the pharmacokinetics and toxicity of
transplacentally transferred drugs.
The potential harm to the fetus from maternal ingestion of
a specific drug depends not only on the drug itself, but on
the dose ingested, the gestational age of the fetus at
exposure, the duration of exposure, the interaction with other
agents to which the fetus is exposed, and, to an unknown
extent, the genetic makeup of the mother and fetus.
Information regarding the safety of drugs in pregnancy
is--derived from animal toxicity data, anecdotal
experience,--registry data, and clinical trials. Data are
limited for antiretroviral drugs, particularly when used in
combination therapy. Drug choice should be individualized and
must be based on discussion with the woman and available data
from preclinical and clinical testing of the individual drugs.
Preclinical data include results of in vitro and animal--in
vivo screening tests for carcinogenicity, clastogenicity/
mutagenicity, and reproductive and teratogenic effects.
However, the predictive value of such tests for adverse
effects in humans is unknown. For example, of approximately
1,200 known animal teratogens, only about 30 are known to be
teratogenic in humans (18). In addition to
antiretroviral agents, certain drugs commonly used to treat
HIV-1--related illnesses demonstrate positive findings on one
or more of these screening tests. For example, acyclovir is
positive in some in vitro carcinogenicity and clastogenicity
assays and is associated with fetal abnormalities in rats;
however, data collected on the--basis of human experience from
the Acyclovir in Pregnancy Registry have indicated no
increased risk for birth defects in infants with in utero
exposure to acyclovir .
Limited data exist regarding placental passage and long-term
animal carcinogenicity for the FDA-approved antiretroviral
drugs (20).
Combination Antiretroviral Therapy and Pregnancy Outcome
Data are conflicting as to whether receipt of combination
antiretroviral therapy during pregnancy is associated
with--adverse pregnancy outcomes such as preterm delivery. A
retrospective Swiss report evaluated the pregnancy outcome of
37 HIV-1--infected pregnant women treated with combination
therapy; all received two reverse transcriptase inhibitors and
16 received one or two protease inhibitors (21). Almost
80% of women experienced one or more typical adverse--effects
of the drugs, such as anemia, nausea/vomiting,--aminotransferase
elevation, or hyperglycemia. A possible--association of
combination antiretroviral therapy with preterm births was
noted; 10 of 30 babies were born prematurely. The preterm
birth rate did not differ between women receiving combination
therapy with or without protease inhibitors. The contribution
of maternal HIV-1 disease stage and other covariates that
might be associated with a risk for prematurity was not
assessed.
The European Collaborative Study and the Swiss Mother +
Child HIV-1 Cohort Study investigated the effects of
combination retroviral therapy in a population of 3,920
mother--child pairs. Adjusting for CD4+
T-lymphocyte count (CD4+ count) and intravenous
drug use, they found a 2.6-fold (95% confidence interval [CI]
= 1.4--4.8) increased odds of preterm--delivery for infants
exposed to combination therapy with or without protease
inhibitors compared with no treatment; women receiving
combination therapy that had been initiated before their
pregnancy were twice as likely to deliver--prematurely as
those starting therapy during the third trimester (22).
However, combination therapy was received by only 323 (8%)
women studied. Exposure to monotherapy was not associated with
prematurity.
In contrast, in an observational study of pregnant women
with HIV-1 infection in the United States (PACTG 367) in which
1,150 (78%) of 1,472 women received combination therapy, no
association was found between receipt of combination therapy
and preterm birth (23). The highest rate of preterm
delivery was among women who had not received any
antiretroviral therapy, which is consistent with several other
reports demonstrating elevated preterm birth rates
among--untreated women with HIV-1 infection (24--26).
In a French open-label study of 445 HIV-1--infected women
receiving ZDV who had lamivudine (3TC) added to their therapy
at 32 weeks' gestation, the rate of preterm delivery was 6%,
similar to the 9% rate in a historical control group of women
receiving only ZDV (27). Additionally, in a large
meta-analysis of seven clinical studies that included 2,123
HIV-infected pregnant women who delivered infants during
1990--1998 and had received antenatal antiretroviral therapy
and 1,143 women who did not receive antenatal antiretroviral
therapy, use of multiple antiretroviral drugs as compared with
no treatment or treatment with one drug was not associated
with increased rates of preterm labor, low birth weight, low
Apgar scores, or--stillbirth (28).
Until more information is known, HIV-1--infected pregnant
women who are receiving combination therapy for their HIV-1
infection should continue their provider-recommended--regimen.
They should receive careful, regular monitoring for pregnancy
complications and for potential toxicities.
Protease Inhibitor Therapy and Hyperglycemia
Hyperglycemia, new-onset diabetes mellitus, exacerbation of
existing diabetes mellitus, and diabetic ketoacidosis have
been reported with receipt of protease inhibitor
antiretroviral drugs by HIV-1--infected patients (29--32).
In addition, pregnancy is itself a risk factor for
hyperglycemia; it is unknown--if the use of protease
inhibitors will increase the risk for--pregnancy-associated
hyperglycemia. Clinicians caring for HIV-1--infected pregnant
women who are receiving protease inhibitor therapy should be
aware of the risk of this complication and closely monitor
glucose levels. Symptoms of hyper-glycemia should be discussed
with pregnant women who are receiving protease inhibitors.
Mitochondrial Toxicity and Nucleoside Analog Drugs
Nucleoside analog drugs are known to induce mitochondrial
dysfunction because the drugs have varying affinity for
mitochondrial gamma DNA polymerase. This affinity can
interfere with mitochondrial replication, resulting in
mitochondrial DNA depletion and dysfunction (33). The
relative potency of the nucleosides in inhibiting
mitochondrial gamma DNA polymerase in vitro is highest for
zalcitabine (ddC), followed by didanosine (ddI), stavudine
(d4T), 3TC, ZDV and abacavir (ABC) (34). Toxicity
related to mitochondrial dysfunction has been reported to
occur in infected patients--receiving long-term treatment with
nucleoside analogs and generally has resolved with
discontinuation of the drug or drugs; a possible genetic
susceptibility to these toxicities has been suggested (33).
These toxicities may be of particular concern for pregnant
women and infants with in utero exposure to nucleoside analog
drugs.
During Pregnancy
Clinical disorders linked to mitochondrial toxicity include
neuropathy, myopathy, cardiomyopathy, pancreatitis, hepatic
steatosis, and lactic acidosis. Among these disorders,
symptomatic lactic acidosis and hepatic steatosis may have a
female preponderance (35). These syndromes have
similarities to rare but life-threatening syndromes that occur
during pregnancy, most often during the third trimester: acute
fatty liver, and the combination of hemolysis, elevated liver
enzymes and low platelets (the HELLP syndrome). Several
investigators have correlated these pregnancy-related
disorders with a recessively inherited mitochondrial
abnormality in the fetus/infant that results in an inability
to oxidize fatty acids (36--38). Since the mother would
be a heterozygotic carrier of the abnormal gene, the risk for
liver toxicity might be increased during pregnancy because the
mother would be unable to properly oxidize both maternal and
accumulating fetal fatty acids (39). Additionally,
animal studies have demonstrated that in late gestation,
pregnant mice have significant reductions (25%--50%) in--mitochondrial
fatty acid oxidation and that exogeneously--administered
estradiol and progesterone can reproduce these effects (40,41);
whether this can be translated to humans is unknown. However,
these data suggest that a disorder of--mitochondrial fatty
acid oxidation in the mother or her fetus during late
pregnancy may play a role in the development of acute fatty
liver of pregnancy and HELLP syndrome and possibly contribute
to susceptibility to antiretroviral-associated mitochondrial
toxicity.
Lactic acidosis with microvacuolar hepatic steatosis is a
toxicity related to nucleoside analog drugs that is thought to
be related to mitochondrial toxicity; it has been reported
to--occur in infected persons treated with nucleoside analog
drugs for long periods (>6 months). Initially, most cases
were associated with ZDV, but later other nucleoside analog
drugs, particularly d4T, have been associated with the
syndrome. In a report from the FDA Spontaneous Adverse Event
Program of 106 patients with this syndrome (60 receiving
combination and 46 receiving single nucleoside analog
therapy), typical initial symptoms included 1 to 6 weeks of
nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, dyspnea, and weakness (35).
Metabolic acidosis with elevated serum lactate and elevated
hepatic enzymes was common. Patients described in that report
were predominantly female and overweight. The incidence of
this syndrome may be increasing, possibly as a result of
increased use of combination nucleoside analog therapy or
increased recognition of the syndrome. In a cohort of infected
patients receiving nucleoside analog therapy followed at Johns
Hopkins University during 1989--1994, the incidence of the
hepatic steatosis syndrome was 0.13% per year (42).
However, in a report from a cohort of 964 HIV-1--infected
persons followed in France--for 2 years during 1997--1999, the
incidence of symptomatic hyperlactatemia was 0.8% per year for
all patients and 1.2% for patients receiving a regimen
including d4T (43).
The frequency of this syndrome in pregnant HIV-1--infected
women receiving nucleoside analog treatment is unknown. In
1999, Italian researchers reported a case of severe lactic
acidosis in an infected pregnant woman who was receiving
d4T-3TC at the time of conception and throughout pregnancy and
who experienced symptoms and fetal death at 38 weeks'
gestation (44). Bristol-Myers Squibb has reported
three--maternal deaths due to lactic acidosis, two with and
one without accompanying pancreatitis, among women who
were--either pregnant or postpartum and whose antepartum
therapy during pregnancy included d4T and ddI in combination
with other antiretroviral agents (either a protease inhibitor
or nevirapine) (45). All women were receiving treatment
with these agents at the time of conception and continued for
the duration of pregnancy; all presented late in gestation
with symptomatic disease that progressed to death in the
immediate postpartum period. Two cases were also associated
with fetal death.
It is unclear if pregnancy augments the incidence of
the--lactic acidosis/hepatic steatosis syndrome that has
been--reported for nonpregnant persons receiving
nucleoside--analog treatment. However, because pregnancy
itself can--mimic some of the early symptoms of the lactic
acidosis/ hepatic steatosis syndrome or be associated with
other disorders of liver metabolism, these cases emphasize the
need for physicians caring for HIV-1--infected pregnant women
receiving nucleoside analog drugs to be alert for early signs
of this syndrome. Pregnant women receiving nucleoside analog
drugs should have hepatic enzymes and electrolytes assessed
more frequently during the last trimester of pregnancy, and
any new symptoms should be evaluated thoroughly.
Additionally,--because of the reports of several cases of
maternal mortality secondary to lactic acidosis with prolonged
use of the combination of d4T and ddI by HIV-1--infected
pregnant women, clinicians should prescribe this
antiretroviral combination during pregnancy with caution and
generally only when other nucleoside analog drug combinations
have failed or have caused unacceptable toxicity or side
effects.
In Utero Exposure
A study conducted in France reported that in a cohort of
1,754 uninfected infants born to HIV-1--infected women who
received antiretroviral drugs during pregnancy, eight infants
with in utero or neonatal exposure to either ZDV-3TC (four
infants) or ZDV alone (four infants) developed indications of
mitochondrial dysfunction after the first few months of life (46).
Two of these infants (both of whom had been exposed to
ZDV-3TC) contracted severe neurologic disease and died, three
had mild to moderate symptoms, and three had no symptoms but
had transient laboratory abnormalities. An association between
these findings and in utero exposure to antiretroviral drugs
has not been definitively established.
In infants followed through age 18 months in PACTG 076, the
occurrence of neurologic events was rare; seizures occurred in
one child exposed to ZDV and two exposed to placebo, and one
child in each group had reported spasticity. Mortality at 18
months was 1.4% among infants given ZDV compared with 3.5%
among those given placebo (47). The Perinatal Safety
Review Working Group performed a retrospective--review of
deaths occurring among children born to HIV-1--infected women
and followed during 1986--1999 in five large prospective U.S.
perinatal cohorts. No deaths similar to those reported from
France or with clinical findings attributable to mitochondrial
dysfunction were identified in a database of >16,000
uninfected children born to HIV-1--infected women with and
without antiretroviral drug exposure (48). However,
most of the infants with antiretroviral exposure had
been--exposed to ZDV alone and only a relatively small
proportion (approximately 6%) had been exposed to ZDV-3TC. In
an African perinatal trial (PETRA) that compared three
regimens of ZDV-3TC (during pregnancy starting at 36 weeks'
gestation, during labor, and through 1 week postpartum; during
labor and postpartum; and during labor only) with placebo for
prevention of transmission, data have been reviewed relating
to neurologic adverse events among 1,798 children who
participated. No increased risk of neurologic events
was--observed among children treated with ZDV-3TC compared
with placebo, regardless of the intensity of treatment (49).
Finally, in a study of 382 uninfected infants born to
HIV-1--infected women, echocardiograms were prospectively
performed every 4 to 6 months during the first 5 years of
life; 9% of infants had been exposed to ZDV prenatally (50).
No--significant differences in ventricular function were
observed between infants exposed and not exposed to ZDV.
Even if the association of mitochondrial dysfunction and in
utero antiretroviral exposures is demonstrated, the
development of severe or fatal mitochondrial disease in these
infants appears to be extremely rare and should be compared
against the clear benefit of ZDV in reducing transmission of a
fatal infection by nearly 70% (51). These results
emphasize the importance of the existing Public Health Service
recommendation for long-term follow-up for any child with in
utero exposure to antiretroviral drugs.
Antiretroviral Pregnancy Registry
Health-care providers who are treating HIV-1--infected
pregnant women and their newborns are strongly advised
to--report instances of prenatal exposure to antiretroviral
drugs (either alone or in combination) to the Antiretroviral
Pregnancy Registry. This registry is an epidemiologic project
to collect observational, nonexperimental data regarding
antiretroviral exposure during pregnancy for the purpose of
assessing the potential teratogenicity of these drugs.
Registry data will be used to supplement animal toxicology
studies and assist clinicians in weighing the potential risks
and benefits of treatment for individual patients. The
Antiretroviral Pregnancy Registry is a collaborative project
of pharmaceutical manufacturers with an advisory committee of
obstetric and pediatric practitioners. The registry does not
use patient names, and registry staff obtain birth outcome
follow-up information from the reporting physician. Referrals
should be directed to
Antiretroviral Pregnancy Registry
Research Park
1011 Ashes Drive
Wilmington, NC 28405
Telephone: 800-258-4263
Fax: 800-800-1052
Update on PACTG 076 Results and Other Studies Relevant to
ZDV Chemoprophylaxis for Perinatal HIV-1 Transmission
In 1996, final results were reported for all 419
infants--enrolled in PACTG 076. The results concur with those
initially reported in 1994; the Kaplan-Meier estimated HIV-1
transmission rate for infants who received placebo was 22.6%,
compared with 7.6% for those who received ZDV, a 66% reduction
in risk for transmission (52).
The mechanism by which ZDV reduced transmission in PACTG
076 participants has not been fully defined. The--effect of
ZDV on maternal HIV-1 RNA does not fully--account for the
observed efficacy of ZDV in reducing transmission. Preexposure
prophylaxis of the fetus or infant may offer substantial
protection. If so, transplacental passage of antiretroviral
drugs would be crucial for prevention of transmission.
Additionally, in placental perfusion studies, ZDV has been
metabolized into the active triphosphate within the placenta (53,54),
which could provide additional protection against in utero
transmission. This phenomenon may be unique to ZDV because
metabolism to the active triphosphate form within the placenta
has not been observed in the other nucleoside analogs that
have been evaluated (i.e., ddI and ddC) (55,56).
In PACTG 076, similar rates of congenital abnormalities
occurred among infants with and without in utero ZDV--exposure.
Data from the Antiretroviral Pregnancy Registry also have
demonstrated no increased risk for congenital abnormalities
among infants born to women who receive ZDV antenatally
compared with the general population (57). Among
uninfected infants from PACTG 076 followed from birth to a
median age of 4.2 years (range 3.2--5.6 years), no differences
were noted in growth, neurodevelopment, or immunologic status
between infants born to mothers who received ZDV compared with
those born to mothers who received placebo (58). No
malignancies have been observed in short-term (i.e., up to age
6 years) follow-up of >727 infants from PACTG 076 or from a
prospective cohort study involving infants with in utero ZDV
exposure (59). However, follow-up is too limited to
provide a definitive assessment of carcinogenic risk with
human exposure. Long-term monitoring continues to be
recommended for all infants who have received in utero ZDV
exposure or in utero exposure to any of the antiretroviral
drugs.
The efficacy of ZDV chemoprophylaxis for reducing HIV-1
transmission among populations of infected women with
characteristics unlike those of the PACTG 076 population has
been evaluated in another perinatal protocol (PACTG 185) and
in prospective cohort studies. PACTG 185 enrolled pregnant
women with advanced HIV-1 disease and low CD4+
counts who were receiving antiretroviral therapy; 24% had
received ZDV before the current pregnancy (60). All
women and infants received the three-part ZDV regimen combined
with either infusions of hyperimmune HIV-1 immunoglobulin (HIVIG)
containing high levels of antibodies to HIV-1 or standard
intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) without HIV-1 antibodies.
Because advanced maternal HIV-1 disease has been associated
with increased risk for perinatal transmission, the
transmission rate in the control group was hypothesized to be
11%--15% despite the administration of ZDV. At the first
interim analysis, the transmission rate for the combined group
was only 4.8% and did not substantially differ by whether the
women received HIVIG or IVIG or by duration of ZDV use (60).
The results of this trial confirm the efficacy of ZDV observed
in PACTG 076 and extend this efficacy to women with advanced
disease, low CD4+ count, and prior ZDV therapy.
Rates of perinatal transmission have been documented to be as
low as 3%--4% among women with HIV-1 infection who receive all
three components of the ZDV regimen,--including women with
advanced HIV-1 disease (6,60).
At least two studies suggest that antenatal use of
combination antiretroviral regimens might further reduce
transmission. In an open-label, nonrandomized study of 445
women with HIV-1 infection in France, 3TC was added at 32
weeks' gestation to standard ZDV prophylaxis; 3TC was also
given to the infant for 6 weeks in addition to ZDV (27).
The transmission rate in the ZDV-3TC group was 1.6% (95% CI =
0.7%--3.3%); in comparison, the transmission rate in a
historical control group of women receiving only ZDV was 6.8%
(95% CI = 5.1%--8.7%). In a longitudinal epidemiologic study
conducted in the United States since 1990, transmission was
observed in 20% of women with HIV-1 infection who--received no
antiretroviral treatment during pregnancy, 10.4% who received
ZDV alone, 3.8% who received combination therapy without
protease inhibitors, and 1.2% who received combination therapy
with protease inhibitors (61).
International Antiretroviral Prophylaxis Clinical Trials
In a trial evaluating short-course antenatal/intrapartum
ZDV prophylaxis and perinatal transmission among
non-breastfeeding women in Thailand, administration of ZDV 300
mg twice daily for 4 weeks antenatally and 300 mg every 3
hours orally during labor was shown to reduce perinatal
transmission by approximately 50% compared with placebo (62).
The transmission rate was 19% in the placebo group versus 9%
in the ZDV group. A second, four-arm factorial design trial in
Thailand compared administration of ZDV antenatally starting
at 28 or 36 weeks' gestation, orally intrapartum, and to the
neonate for 3 days or 6 weeks. At an interim analysis, the
transmission rate in the arm receiving ZDV antenatally
starting at 36 weeks and postnatally for 3 days to the infant
was 10%, which was significantly higher than for the
long--long arm (antenatal starting at 28 weeks and infant
administration for 6 weeks) (63). The transmission rate
in the short--short arm of this study was similar to the 9%
observed with short antenatal/intrapartum ZDV in the first
Thai study. The rate of in utero transmission was higher among
women in the short antenatal arms compared with those
receiving longer antenatal therapy, suggesting that longer
treatment of the infant cannot substitute for longer treatment
of the mother.
A third trial in Africa (PETRA trial) among breastfeeding
HIV-1--infected women has shown that a combination regimen of
ZDV and 3TC administered starting at 36 weeks' gestation,
orally intrapartum, and for 1 week postpartum to the woman and
infant reduced transmission at age 6 weeks by approximately
50% compared with placebo (64). The transmission rate
at age 6 weeks was 15% in the placebo group versus 6% with the
three-part ZDV-3TC regimen. This efficacy is similar to the
efficacy observed in the Thailand study of antepartum/intrapartum
short-course ZDV in non-breastfeeding women (62).
Investigators have identified two possible intrapartum/
postpartum regimens (either ZDV-3TC or nevirapine) that could
provide an effective intrapartum/postpartum intervention for
women for whom the diagnosis of HIV-1 is not made until near
to or during labor. The PETRA African ZDV-3TC trial among
breastfeeding HIV-1--infected women also--demonstrated that an
intrapartum/postpartum regimen, started during labor and
continued for 1 week postpartum in the woman and infant,
reduced transmission at age 6 weeks from 15% in the placebo
group to 9% in the group receiving the two-part ZDV-3TC
regimen, a reduction of 40% (64). In this trial, oral
ZDV-3TC administered solely during--the intrapartum period was
not effective in lowering--transmission. Another study in
Uganda (HIVNET 012), again in a breastfeeding population,
demonstrated that a single--200-mg oral dose of nevirapine
given to the mother at onset of labor combined with a single
2-mg/kg oral dose given to her infant at age 48--72 hours
reduced transmission by nearly 50% compared with a very short
regimen of ZDV given orally during labor and to the infant for
1 week (65). Transmission at age 6 weeks was 12% in the
nevirapine group compared with 21% in the ZDV group. A
subsequent trial in South Africa demonstrated similar
transmission rates with a modified HIVNET 012 nevirapine
regimen (nevirapine given to the woman as a single dose during
labor with a second dose at 48 hours postpartum, and a single
dose to the infant at age--48 hours) compared with the PETRA
regimen of oral ZDV-3TC during labor and for 1 week after
delivery to the mother and infant (66). Transmission
rates at age 8 weeks were 13.3% in the nevirapine arm and
10.9% in the ZDV-3TC arm.
Two clinical trials have suggested that the addition of the
HIVNET 012 single-dose nevirapine regimen to short-course ZDV
may provide increased efficacy in reducing perinatal
transmission. A study of nonbreastfeeding women in--Thailand
compared a short-course ZDV regimen (starting at 28 weeks'
gestation, given orally intrapartum, and for 1 week to the
infant) with two combination regimens: short-course ZDV plus
single-dose intrapartum/neonatal nevirapine, and short-course
ZDV plus intrapartum maternal nevirapine only. In the
short-course ZDV-only arm, enrollment was discontinued by the
Data and Safety Monitoring Board at the first--interim
analysis because transmission was significantly higher among
those receiving ZDV alone compared with those--receiving the
intrapartum/neonatal nevirapine combination regimen (67).
The study is continuing to enroll to allow comparison of the
two combination arms. A second open-label study in Cote
d'Ivoire reported a 7.1% transmission rate at age 4 weeks with
administration of short-course ZDV (starting at 36 weeks,
given orally intrapartum, and for 1 week to the infant)
combined with single-dose intrapartum/neonatal nevirapine.
This was lower than for a nonconcurrent historical control
group receiving ZDV alone (68).
In contrast to these studies, which evaluated combining
single-dose nevirapine with short-course ZDV, a study in the
United States, Europe, Brazil, and the Bahamas (PACTG 316)
evaluated whether the addition of the HIVNET 012 single-dose
nevirapine regimen to standard antiretroviral therapy (at
minimum the 3-part full ZDV regimen) would provide additional
benefits in lowering transmission. In this study, 1,506
pregnant women with HIV-1 infection who were receiving
antiretroviral therapy (77% were receiving combination
antiretroviral regimens) were randomized to receive a single
dose of nevirapine or nevirapine placebo at onset of labor,
and their infants received a single dose (according to the
maternal randomization) at age 48 hours. Transmission was not
significantly different between groups, occurring in 1.6% of
women in the placebo group and 1.4% among women in the
nevirapine group (69).
Certain data indicate that postexposure antiretroviral
prophylaxis of infants whose mothers did not receive
antepartum or intrapartum antiretroviral drugs might provide
some protection against transmission. Although data from some
epidemiologic studies do not support efficacy of postnatal ZDV
alone, other data demonstrate efficacy if ZDV is started
rapidly following birth (6,70,71). In a study from
North--Carolina, the rate of infection among HIV-1--exposed
infants who received only postpartum ZDV chemoprophylaxis was
similar to that observed among infants who received no ZDV
chemoprophylaxis (6). However, another epidemiologic
study from New York State determined that administration of
ZDV to the neonate for 6 weeks was associated with a
significant--reduction in transmission if the drug was
initiated within 24 hours of birth (the majority of infants
started within 12 hours) (70,71). Consistent with a
possible preventive effect of rapid postexposure prophylaxis,
a retrospective case-control study of health-care workers from
the United States, France, and the United Kingdom who had
nosocomial exposure to--HIV-1--infected blood determined that
postexposure use of ZDV was associated with reduced odds of
contracting HIV-1--(adjusted odds ratio = 0.2; 95% CI =
0.1--0.6) .
Several ongoing clinical trials are attempting to determine
the optimal postexposure antiretroviral prophylaxis regimen
for--infants.
Perinatal HIV-1 Transmission and Maternal HIV-1 RNA Copy
Number
The correlation of HIV-1 RNA levels with risk for disease
progression in nonpregnant infected adults suggests that HIV-1
RNA should be monitored during pregnancy at least as often as
recommended for persons who are not pregnant (i.e., every 3 to
4 months or approximately once each trimester). In addition,
HIV-1 RNA levels should be evaluated at 34--36 weeks of
gestation to allow discussion of options for mode of delivery
based on HIV-1 RNA results and clinical circumstances.
Although no data indicate that pregnancy accelerates HIV-1
disease progression, longitudinal measurements of HIV-1 RNA
levels during and after pregnancy have been evaluated in only
a limited number of prospective cohort studies. In one cohort
of 198 HIV-1--infected women, plasma HIV-1 RNA levels were
higher at 6 months postpartum than during pregnancy in many
women; this increase was observed in women regardless of ZDV
use during and after pregnancy (73).
Initial data regarding the correlation of viral load with
risk for perinatal transmission were conflicting, with some
studies suggesting an absolute correlation between HIV-1 RNA
copy number and risk of transmission (74). However,
although higher HIV-1 RNA levels have been observed among
women who transmitted HIV-1 to their infants, overlap in HIV-1
RNA copy number has been observed in women who transmitted and
those who did not transmit the virus. Transmission has been
observed across the entire range of HIV-1 RNA levels
(including in women with HIV-1 RNA copy number below the limit
of detection of the assay), and the predictive value of RNA
copy number for transmission in an individual woman has been
relatively poor (73,75,76). In PACTG 076, antenatal
maternal HIV-1 RNA copy number was associated with HIV-1
transmission in women receiving placebo. In women receiving
ZDV, the relationship was markedly attenuated and no longer
statistically significant (52). An HIV-1 RNA threshold
below which there was no risk for transmission was not
identified; ZDV was effective in reducing transmission
regardless of maternal HIV-1 RNA copy number (52,77).
More recent data from larger numbers of ZDV-treated--infected
pregnant women indicate that HIV-1 RNA levels correlate with
risk of transmission even among women treated with
antiretroviral agents (62,78--80). Although the risk
for perinatal transmission in women with HIV-1 RNA below the
level of assay quantitation appears to be extremely low,
transmission from mother to infant has been reported among
women with all levels of maternal HIV-1 RNA. Additionally,
although HIV-1 RNA may be an important risk factor for
transmission, other factors also appear to play a role (80--82).
Although there is a general correlation between viral load
in plasma and in the genital tract, discordance has also
been--reported, particularly between HIV-1 proviral load in
blood and genital secretions (83--86). If exposure to
HIV-1 in the maternal genital tract during delivery is a risk
factor for perinatal transmission, plasma HIV-1 RNA levels
might not--always be an accurate indicator of risk. Long-term
changes in one compartment (such as can occur with
antiretroviral treatment) may or may not be associated with
comparable changes in other body compartments. Further studies
are needed to determine the effect of antiretroviral drugs on
genital tract viral load and the association of such effects
on the risk of perinatal HIV-1 transmission. In the
short-course ZDV trial in Thailand, plasma and cervicovaginal
HIV-1 RNA levels were reduced by ZDV treatment, and each
independently correlated with perinatal transmission (87).
The full ZDV chemoprophylaxis regimen, alone or in combination
with other antiretroviral agents, including intravenous ZDV
during delivery and the administration of ZDV to the infant
for the first 6 weeks of life, should be discussed with and
offered to all infected pregnant women regardless of their
HIV-1 RNA level.
Results of epidemiologic and clinical trials suggest that
women receiving highly active antiretroviral regimens
that--effectively reduce HIV-1 RNA to <1,000 copies/mL or
undetectable levels have very low rates of perinatal
transmission (27,61,69,88). However, since transmission
can occur even at low or undetectable HIV-1 RNA copy numbers,
RNA levels should not be a determining factor when deciding
whether to use ZDV for chemoprophylaxis. Additionally, the
efficacy of ZDV is not solely related to lowering viral load.
In one study of 44 HIV-1--infected pregnant women, ZDV was
effective in reducing transmission despite minimal effect on
HIV-1 RNA levels (89). These results are similar to
those observed in PACTG 076 (52). Antiretroviral
prophylaxis reduces transmission even among women with HIV-1
RNA levels <1,000 copies/mL (90). Therefore, at a
minimum, ZDV prophylaxis should be given even to women who
have a very low or--undetectable plasma viral load.
Preconception Counseling and Care for
HIV-1--Infected Women of Childbearing Age
Many women infected with HIV-1 (nearly 60% in some centers)
enter pregnancy with a known diagnosis, and nearly half of
these women enter the first trimester of pregnancy--receiving
treatment with single or multiagent antiretroviral therapy (91).
Additionally, as many as 40% of women who have begun
antiretroviral therapy before their pregnancy might--require
adjustment of their therapeutic regimen during their pregnancy
course.
The American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology advocates
extending to all women of childbearing age the opportunity to
receive preconception counseling as a component of routine
primary medical care. It is recognized that >40% of
pregnancies may be unintended and that the diagnosis of
pregnancy most frequently occurs late in the first trimester
when organogenesis is nearly completed. Preconception care can
identify risk factors for adverse maternal or fetal outcome
(e.g., age, diabetes, hypertension), provide education and
counseling targeted to the patient's individual needs, and
treat or stabilize medical conditions before conception to
optimize maternal and fetal outcomes (92).
For women with HIV-1 infection, preconception care must
also focus on maternal infection status, viral load, immune
status, and therapeutic regimen as well as education regarding
perinatal transmission risks and prevention strategies,--
expectations for the child's future, and, where desired,
effective contraception until the optimal maternal health
status for pregnancy is achieved.
The following components of preconception counseling are
recommended for HIV-1--infected women:
- selection of effective and appropriate contraceptive
methods to reduce the likelihood of unintended pregnancy;
- education and counseling about perinatal transmission
risks, strategies to reduce those risks, and potential
effects of HIV-1 or treatment on pregnancy course and
outcomes;
- initiation or modification of antiretroviral therapy:
--- avoid agents with potential reproductive toxicity for
the developing fetus (e.g., efavirenz, hydroxyurea) (20),
--- choose agents effective in reducing the risk of
perinatal HIV-1 transmission,
--- attain a stable, maximally suppressed maternal viral
load,
--- evaluate and control for therapy-associated side
effects that may adversely affect maternal/fetal health
outcomes (e.g., hyperglycemia, anemia, hepatic toxicity),
- evaluation and appropriate prophylaxis for opportunistic
infections and administration of medical immunizations
(e.g., influenza, pneumococcal, or hepatitis B vaccines)
as indicated;
- optimization of maternal nutritional status;
- institution of the standard measures for preconception
evaluation and management (e.g., assessment of
reproductive and familial genetic history, screening for
infectious diseases/sexually transmitted diseases, and
initiation of folic acid supplementation);
- screening for maternal psychological and substance abuse
disorders; and
- planning for perinatal consultation if desired or
indicated.
HIV-1--infected women of childbearing potential receive
primary health-care services in various clinical settings,
e.g., family planning, family medicine, internal medicine,
obstetrics/ gynecology. It is imperative that primary
health-care providers consider the fundamental principles of
preconception counseling an integral component of
comprehensive primary health care for improving maternal/child
health outcomes.
General Principles Regarding the Use of
Antiretroviral Agents in Pregnancy
Medical care of the HIV-1--infected pregnant
woman--requires coordination and communication between the HIV
specialist caring for the woman when she is not pregnant and
her obstetrician. Decisions regarding use of antiretroviral
drugs during pregnancy should be made by the woman after
discussion with her health-care provider about the known
and--unknown benefits and risks of therapy. Initial evaluation
of an infected pregnant woman should include an assessment of
HIV-1 disease status and recommendations regarding
antiretroviral treatment or alteration of her current
anti-retroviral regimen.
This assessment should include the following:
- evaluation of the degree of existing
immunodeficiency--determined by CD4+ count;
- risk for disease progression as determined by the level
of plasma RNA;
- history of prior or current antiretroviral therapy;
- gestational age; and
- supportive care needs.
Decisions regarding initiation of therapy should be the
same for women who are not currently receiving antiretroviral
therapy and for women who are not pregnant, with the
additional consideration of the potential impact of such
therapy on the fetus and infant .
Similarly, for women currently receiving antiretroviral
therapy, decisions regarding alterations in therapy should
involve the same considerations as those used for women who
are not pregnant. The three-part ZDV chemoprophylaxis regimen,
alone or in combination with other antiretroviral agents,
should be discussed with and--offered to all infected pregnant
women to reduce the risk for perinatal HIV-1 transmission.
Decisions regarding the use and choice of antiretroviral
drugs during pregnancy are complex; several competing
factors--influencing risk and benefit must be weighed.
Discussion--regarding the use of antiretroviral drugs during
pregnancy should include the following:
- what is known and not known about the effects of such
drugs on the fetus and newborn, including lack of
long-term outcome data on the use of any of the available
antiretroviral drugs during pregnancy;
- what treatment is recommended for the health of the
HIV-1--infected woman; and
- the efficacy of ZDV for reduction of perinatal
HIV-1--transmission.
Results from preclinical and animal studies and available
clinical information about use of the various antiretroviral
agents during pregnancy also should be discussed (20).
The hypothetical risks of these drugs during pregnancy should
be placed in perspective with the proven benefit of
antiretroviral therapy for the health of the infected woman
and the benefit of ZDV chemoprophylaxis for reducing the risk
for HIV-1 transmission to her infant.
Discussion of treatment options should be noncoercive, and
the final decision regarding use of antiretroviral drugs is
the responsibility of the woman. Decisions regarding use and
choice of antiretroviral drugs for persons who are not
pregnant are becoming increasingly complicated as the standard
of care moves toward simultaneous use of multiple
antiretroviral drugs to suppress viral replication below
detectable limits. These decisions are further complicated in
pregnancy because the long-term consequences for the infant
who has been exposed to antiretroviral drugs in utero are
unknown. A woman's decision to refuse treatment with ZDV or
other drugs should not result in punitive action or denial of
care. Further, use of ZDV alone should not be denied to a
woman who wishes to minimize exposure of the fetus to other
antiretroviral drugs and therefore, after counseling, chooses
to receive only ZDV during pregnancy to reduce the risk for
perinatal transmission.
A long-term treatment plan should be developed after
discussion between the patient and the health-care provider
and should emphasize the importance of adherence to any
prescribed antiretroviral regimen. Depending on individual
circumstances, provision of support services, mental health
services, and drug abuse treatment may be required.
Coordination of services among prenatal care providers,
primary care and HIV-1 specialty care providers, mental health
and drug abuse treatment services, and public assistance
programs is essential to ensure adherence of the infected
woman to antiretroviral treatment regimens.
General counseling should include what is known regarding
risk factors for perinatal transmission. Cigarette
smoking,--illicit drug use, and unprotected sexual intercourse
with multiple partners during pregnancy have been associated
with risk for perinatal HIV-1 transmission (93--97),
and discontinuing these practices might reduce this risk. In
addition, CDC recommends that infected women in the United
States refrain from breastfeeding to avoid postnatal
transmission of HIV-1 to their infants through breast milk ;
these recommendations also should be followed by women
receiving antiretroviral therapy. Passage of antiretroviral
drugs into breast milk has been evaluated for only a few
antiretroviral drugs. ZDV, 3TC, and nevirapine can be detected
in the breast milk of women, and ddI, d4T, abacavir,
delavirdine, indinavir, ritonavir, saquinavir and amprenavir
can be detected in the breast milk of lactating rats. Limited
data are available regarding either the efficacy of
antiretroviral therapy for the prevention of postnatal
transmission of HIV-1 through breast milk or the toxicity of
long-term antiretroviral exposure of the--infant through
breast milk.
Women who must temporarily discontinue therapy because of
pregnancy-related hyperemesis should not resume therapy until
sufficient time has elapsed to ensure that the drugs will be
tolerated. To reduce the potential for emergence of
resistance, if therapy requires temporary discontinuation for
any reason during pregnancy, all drugs should be stopped
and--reintroduced simultaneously.
Recommendations for Antiretroviral
Chemoprophylaxis to Reduce Perinatal HIV-1 Transmission
The following recommendations for use of anti-retroviral
chemoprophylaxis to reduce the risk for perinatal transmission
are based on situations that may be commonly encountered in
clinical practice , with relevant considerations highlighted
in the subsequent discussion sections. These recommendations
are only guidelines, and flexibility should be exercised
according to the patient's individual circumstances. In the
1994 recommendations ,
six clinical situations were delineated on the basis of
maternal CD4+ count, weeks of gestation, and prior
antiretroviral use.--Because current data indicate that the
PACTG 076 ZDV regimen also is effective for women with
advanced disease, low CD4+ count, and prior ZDV
therapy, clinical situations based on CD4+ count
and prior ZDV use are not presented. Additionally, because
data indicate that most transmission occurs near the time of
or during delivery, ZDV chemoprophylaxis is recommended
regardless of weeks of gestation; thus, clinical situations
based on weeks of gestation also are not--presented.
The antenatal dosing regimen in PACTG 076 (100
mg--administered orally five times daily) was selected on the basis of the standard ZDV dosage
for adults at the time of the study. However, recent data have
indicated that administration of ZDV three times daily will
maintain intracellular ZDV triphosphate at levels comparable
with those observed with more frequent dosing (99--101).
Comparable clinical response also has been observed in some
clinical trials among persons receiving ZDV twice daily (102--104).
Thus, the current standard ZDV dosing regimen for adults is
200 mg three times daily, or 300 mg twice daily. Because the
mechanism by which ZDV reduces perinatal transmission is not
known, these dosing regimens may not have equivalent efficacy
to that--observed in PACTG 076. However, a regimen of two or
three times daily is expected to increase adherence to the
regimen.
The recommended ZDV dosage for infants was derived from
pharmacokinetic studies performed among full-term infants (105).
ZDV is primarily cleared through hepatic glucuronidation to an
inactive metabolite. The glucuronidation metabolic enzyme
system is immature in neonates, leading to prolonged ZDV
half-life and clearance compared with older infants (ZDV
half-life: 3.1 hours versus 1.9 hours; clearance: 10.9 versus
19.0 mL/minute/kg body weight, respectively). Because
premature infants have even greater immaturity in hepatic
metabolic function than full-term infants, further
prolongation of clearance may be expected. In a study of 15
premature infants who were at 26--33 weeks' gestation and who
received different ZDV dosing regimens, mean ZDV half-life was
7.2 hours and mean clearance was 2.5 mL/minute/kg body weight
during the first 10 days of life (106). At a mean age
of 18 days, a decrease in half-life (4.4 hours) and increase
in clearance (4.3 mL/minute/kg body weight) were found.
The--appropriate ZDV dosage for premature infants has not been
defined but is being evaluated in a phase I clinical trial
among premature infants <34 weeks' gestation. The dosing
regimen being studied is 1.5 mg/kg body weight orally or
intravenously every 12 hours for the first 2 weeks of life;
for infants aged--2 to 6 weeks, the dose is increased to 2
mg/kg body weight every 8 hours.
Clinical Situations and Recommendations for Use--of
Antiretroviral Prophylaxis
1. HIV-1--infected pregnant women who have not received
prior antiretroviral therapy
Recommendation. Pregnant women with HIV-1 infection
must receive standard clinical, immunologic, and virologic
evaluation. Recommendations for initiation and choice of
antiretroviral therapy should be based on the same parameters
used for persons who are not pregnant, although the known and
unknown risks and benefits of such therapy during pregnancy
must be considered and discussed. The three-part ZDV
chemoprophylaxis regimen, initiated after the first trimester,
should be recommended for all pregnant women with HIV-1
infection regardless of antenatal HIV-1 RNA copy number to
reduce the risk for perinatal transmission. The combination of
ZDV chemoprophylaxis with additional antiretroviral drugs for
treatment of HIV-1 infection is recommended for infected women
whose clinical, immunologic, or virologic status--requires
treatment or whose HIV-1 RNA is >1,000 copies/mL
regardless of their clinical or immunologic status. Women who
are in the first trimester of pregnancy may consider--delaying
initiation of therapy until after 10--12 weeks'--gestation.
Discussion. When ZDV is administered in the three-part
PACTG 076 regimen, perinatal transmission is reduced by
approximately 70%. Although the mechanism by which ZDV reduces
transmission is not known, protection is likely multifactorial.
Preexposure prophylaxis of the infant is provided by passage
of ZDV across the placenta so that inhibitory levels of the
drug are present in the fetus during the birth
process.--Although placental passage of ZDV is excellent, that
of other antiretroviral drugs is variable . Therefore, when combination antiretroviral therapy is
initiated during pregnancy, ZDV should be included as a
component of antenatal therapy whenever possible. Because the
mechanism by which ZDV reduces transmission is not known, the
intrapartum and newborn ZDV components of the
chemoprophylactic regimen should be administered to reduce
perinatal HIV-1 transmission. If a woman does not receive ZDV
as a component of her antenatal antiretroviral regimen,
intrapartum and newborn ZDV should still be recommended.
Because of the evolving and complex nature of the
management of HIV-1 infection, a specialist with experience in
the treatment of pregnant women with HIV-1 infection should be
involved in their care. Women should be informed that--potent
combination antiretroviral regimens have substantial benefit
for their own health and may provide enhanced protection
against perinatal transmission. Several studies have indicated
that for women with low or undetectable HIV-1 RNA levels
(e.g., <1,000 copies/mL) rates of perinatal--transmission
are extremely low, particularly when they have received
antiretroviral therapy (61,78,79). However, there is no
threshold below which lack of transmission can be assured, and
the long-term effects of in utero exposure to multiple
antiretroviral drugs are unknown. Decisions regarding the use
and choice of an antiretroviral regimen should be
individualized based on discussion with the woman about the
following factors:
- her risk for disease progression and the risks and
benefits of delaying initiation of therapy;
- possible benefit of lowering viral load for reducing
perinatal transmission;
- potential drug toxicities and interactions with other
drugs
- the need for strict adherence to the prescribed drug
schedule to avoid the development of drug resistance;
- unknown long-term effects of in utero drug exposure on
the infant; and
- preclinical, animal, and clinical data relevant to use
of the currently available antiretroviral agents during
pregnancy.
Because the period of organogenesis (when the fetus is most
susceptible to potential teratogenic effects of drugs) is
during the first 10 weeks of gestation and the risks of
antiretroviral therapy during that period are unknown, women
in the first trimester of pregnancy might wish to delay
initiation of therapy until after 10--12 weeks' gestation.
This decision should be carefully considered by the
health-care provider and the--patient; a discussion should
include an assessment of the woman's health status, the
benefits and risks of delaying initiation of therapy for
several weeks, and the fact that most perinatal HIV-1
transmission likely occurs late in pregnancy or during
delivery. Treatment with efavirenz should be avoided during
the first trimester because significant teratogenic--effects
in rhesus macaques were seen at drug exposures similar to
those representing human exposure(20). Hydroxyurea is a potent teratogen in a
variety of animal species and should also be avoided during
the first trimester.
When initiation of antiretroviral therapy is
considered--optional on the basis of current guidelines for
treatment of nonpregnant persons ,
infected pregnant women should be counseled regarding the
potential benefits of standard combination therapy and should
be offered such therapy, including the three-part ZDV
chemoprophylaxis regimen. Although such women are at low risk
for clinical disease progression if combination therapy is
delayed, antiretroviral therapy that successfully reduces
HIV-1 RNA to levels <1,000 copies/mL may substantially
lower the risk of perinatal HIV-1 transmission and lessen the
need for consideration of elective cesarean--delivery as an
intervention to reduce transmission risk.
When combination therapy is administered, the regimen
should be chosen from those recommended for nonpregnant adults .
Dual nucleoside analog therapy without the--addition of either
a protease inhibitor or nonnucleoside--reverse transcriptase
inhibitor is not recommended for nonpregnant adults because of
the potential for inadequate viral suppression and rapid
development of resistance (107). For pregnant women not
meeting the criteria for antiretroviral therapy for their own
health, and receiving antiretroviral drugs only for prevention
of perinatal transmission (e.g., those with HIV-1 RNA
<1,000 copies/mL), dual nucleoside therapy may be
considered in selected circumstances. If combination therapy
is given principally to reduce perinatal transmission and
would have been optional if the woman were not pregnant,
consideration may be given to discontinuing therapy
postnatally, with the option to reinitiate treatment according
to standard criteria for nonpregnant women. If drugs are
discontinued postnatally, all drugs should be stopped
simultaneously. Discussion regarding the decision to continue
or stop combination therapy postpartum should occur before
beginning therapy during pregnancy.
Antiretroviral prophylaxis has been beneficial in
preventing perinatal transmission even for infected pregnant
women with HIV-1 RNA levels <1,000 copies/mL. In a
meta-analysis of factors associated with perinatal
transmission among women whose infants were infected despite
the women's having HIV-1 RNA <1,000 copies/mL at or near
delivery, transmission was only 1.0% among women receiving
antenatal antiretroviral therapy (primarily ZDV alone)
compared with 9.8% among those receiving no antenatal therapy
(90). Therefore, use of antiretroviral prophylaxis is
recommended for all pregnant women with HIV-1 infection
regardless of antenatal HIV-1 RNA level.
The time-limited use of ZDV alone during pregnancy for
chemoprophylaxis against perinatal transmission is
controversial. Standard combination antiretroviral regimens
for treatment of HIV-1 infection should be discussed and
should be offered to all pregnant women with HIV-1 infection
regardless of viral load; they are recommended for all
pregnant women with HIV-1 RNA levels >1,000 copies/mL.
Some women may wish to restrict exposure of their fetus to
antiretroviral drugs during pregnancy and still reduce the
risk of transmitting HIV-1 to their infant. Additionally, for
women with HIV-1 RNA levels <1,000 copies/mL, time-limited
use of ZDV during the second and third trimesters of pregnancy
is less likely to--induce the development of resistance
because of the limited viral replication existing in the
patient and the time-limited exposure to the antiretroviral
drug. For example, the development of ZDV resistance was
unusual among the healthy population of women who participated
in PACTG 076 (108). The use of ZDV chemoprophylaxis
alone (or, in selected circumstances, dual nucleosides) during
pregnancy might be an--appropriate option for these women.
2. HIV-1--infected women receiving antiretroviral therapy
during the current pregnancy
Recommendation. HIV-1 infected women receiving
antiretroviral therapy whose pregnancy is identified after the
first trimester should continue therapy. ZDV should be a
component of the antenatal antiretroviral treatment regimen
after the first trimester whenever possible, although this may
not always be feasible. Women receiving antiretroviral therapy
whose pregnancy is recognized during the first trimester
should be counseled regarding the benefits and potential risks
of antiretroviral administration during this period, and
continuation of therapy should be considered. If therapy is
discontinued during the first trimester, all drugs should be
stopped and reintroduced simultaneously to avoid the
development of drug resistance. Regardless of the antepartum
antiretroviral--regimen, ZDV administration is recommended
during the--intrapartum period and for the newborn.
Discussion. Women who have been receiving antiretroviral
treatment for their HIV-1 infection should continue treatment
during pregnancy. Discontinuation of therapy could lead to an
increase in viral load, which could result in decline
in--immune status and disease progression as well as
adverse--consequences for both the fetus and the woman.
Although ZDV should be a component of the antenatal
antiretroviral treatment whenever possible, there may be
circumstances, such as the occurrence of significant ZDV-related
toxicity, when this is not feasible. Additionally,
women--receiving an antiretroviral regimen that does not
contain ZDV but who have HIV-1 RNA levels that are
consistently very low or undetectable (e.g., <1,000 copies/mL)
have a very low risk of perinatal transmission (61),
and there may be concerns that the addition of ZDV to the
current regimen could--compromise adherence to treatment.
The maternal antenatal antiretroviral treatment regimen
should be continued on schedule as much as possible during
labor to provide maximal virologic effect and to minimize the
chance of development of drug resistance. If a woman has not
received ZDV as a component of her antenatal therapeutic
antiretroviral regimen, intravenous ZDV should still
be--administered during the intrapartum period whenever
feasible. ZDV and d4T should not be administered together
because of potential pharmacologic antagonsim; options for
women receiving oral d4T as part of their antenatal therapy
include either continuation of oral d4T during labor without
intravenous ZDV or withholding oral d4T during the period
of--intravenous ZDV administration during labor. Additionally,
the infant should receive the standard 6-week course of ZDV.
For women with suboptimal suppression of HIV-1 RNA (i.e., >1,000
copies/mL) near the time of delivery despite having received
prenatal ZDV prophylaxis with or without combination
antiretroviral therapy, it is not known if administration of
additional antiretroviral drugs during labor and delivery
provides added protection against perinatal transmission. In
the HIVNET 012 study among Ugandan women who had not received
antenatal antiretroviral therapy, a 2-dose nevirapine regimen
(single dose to the woman at the onset of labor and single
dose to the infant at age 48 hours) significantly reduced
perinatal transmission compared with a very short intrapartum/1
week postpartum ZDV regimen (65). For women in the
United States, Europe, Brazil, and the Bahamas receiving
antenatal antiretroviral therapy, addition of the--2-dose
nevirapine regimen did not result in lower transmission rates
(69). Given the lack of further reduction of
transmission with nevirapine added to one of the standard
antepartum regimens used in developed countries and the
potential development of nevirapine resistance (See
Antiretroviral Drug Resistance and Resistance Testing in
Pregnancy), addition of nevirapine during labor for
women--already receiving antiretroviral therapy is not
recommended in the United States.
Women receiving antiretroviral therapy may realize they are
pregnant early in gestation and want to consider temporarily
stopping antiretroviral treatment until after the first
trimester because of concern for potential teratogenicity.
Data are--insufficient to support or refute the teratogenic
risk of antiretroviral drugs when administered during the
first--10 weeks of gestation; certain drugs are of more
concern than others (20). The decision to continue therapy during
the first trimester should be carefully considered by the
clinician and the pregnant woman. Discussions should include
considerations such as gestational age of the fetus; the
woman's clinical, immunologic, and virologic status; and the
known and unknown potential effects of the antiretroviral
drugs on the fetus. If antiretroviral therapy is discontinued
during the first trimester, all agents should be stopped and
restarted--simultaneously in the second trimester to avoid the
development of drug resistance. No data are available to
address whether temporary discontinuation of therapy is
harmful for the woman or fetus.
Health-care providers might consider administering ZDV in
combination with other antiretroviral drugs to newborns of
women with a history of prior antiretroviral therapy,
particularly in situations in which the woman is infected with
HIV-1 with documented high-level ZDV resistance, has had
disease progression while receiving ZDV, or has had extensive
prior ZDV monotherapy. The efficacy of this approach is
unknown but would be analogous to the use of multiple agents
for postexposure prophylaxis for adults after
inadvertent--exposure. However, the appropriate dosage and
short- and long-term safety of many antiretroviral agents in
the neonate has not been established. The half-lives of ZDV,
3TC, and nevirapine are prolonged during the neonatal period
because of immature liver metabolism and renal function,
requiring specific dosing adjustments when these agents are
administered to neonates. Optimal dosages for protease
inhibitors in the neonatal period are still under study. The
infected woman should be counseled regarding the theoretical
benefit of combination antiretroviral drugs for the neonate,
potential risks, and available data on appropriate dosing. She
should also be informed that using antiretroviral drugs in
addition to ZDV for prophylaxis of newborns is of unknown
efficacy in reducing risk of perinatal transmission.
3. HIV-1--Infected Women in Labor Who Have Had No Prior
Therapy
Recommendation. Several effective regimens are
available for intrapartum therapy for women who have had no
prior therapy
- a single dose of nevirapine at onset of labor followed
by a single dose of nevirapine for the newborn at age 48
hours;
- oral ZDV and 3TC during labor, followed by 1 week of
oral ZDV-3TC for the newborn;
- intrapartum intravenous ZDV followed by 6 weeks of ZDV
for the newborn; and
- the 2-dose nevirapine regimen combined with intrapartum
intravenous ZDV and 6 weeks of ZDV for the--newborn.
In the immediate postpartum period, the woman should have
appropriate assessments (e.g., CD4+ count and HIV-1
RNA copy number) to determine whether antiretroviral therapy
is recommended for her own health.
Discussion. Although intrapartum antiretroviral
medications will not prevent perinatal transmission that
occurs--before labor, most transmission occurs near to or
during labor and delivery. Preexposure prophylaxis for the
fetus can be provided by giving the mother a drug that rapidly
crosses the placenta to produce systemic antiretroviral drug
levels in the fetus during intensive exposure to HIV-1 in
maternal genital secretions and blood during birth.
Several intrapartum/neonatal antiretroviral prophylaxis
regimens are applicable for women in labor who have had no
prior antiretroviral therapy . Two regimens, one--using 2 doses of nevirapine (one
each for the mother and--infant) and the other a combination
of ZDV and 3TC, were shown to reduce perinatal transmission in
randomized clinical trials among breastfeeding women, and
available epidemiologic data suggest the efficacy of a third,
ZDV-only regimen. The fourth regimen, combining ZDV with
nevirapine, is based upon theoretical considerations.
In the HIVNET 012 trial, conducted in Uganda, a regimen
consisting of a single dose of oral nevirapine given to the
woman at onset of labor and a single dose to the infant at age
48 hours was compared with oral ZDV given to the woman every 3
hours during labor and postnatally to the infant for--7 days . At age 6 weeks, the rates of transmission were 12%
(95% CI = 8%--16%) in the nevirapine arm versus 21% (95% CI =
16%--26%) in the ZDV arm, a 47% reduction (95% CI = 20%--64%)
in transmission (65). No serious short-term toxicity
was observed in either group. Because no placebo group was
included, no conclusions can be drawn regarding the efficacy
of the intrapartum/1-week neonatal ZDV regimen versus no
treatment.
In the PETRA trial, conducted in Uganda, South Africa, and
Tanzania, ZDV and 3TC were administered orally intrapartum and
to the woman and infant for 7 days postnatally. Oral ZDV and
3TC were administered at the onset of labor and continued
until delivery Postnatally, the woman and infant received ZDV and 3TC
every 12 hours for 7 days. At age 6 weeks, the rates of
transmission were 9% in the ZDV-3TC arm versus 15% in the
placebo arm, a 40% reduction in transmission (64).
However, no differences in transmission were observed when
oral ZDV and 3TC were administered only during the intrapartum
period (transmission of 14% in the ZDV-3TC arm versus 15% in
the placebo arm), indicating that some postexposure
prophylaxis is needed, at least in breastfeeding settings.
These clinical trials were conducted in Africa, where the
majority of women breastfeed their infants. Because HIV-1 can
be transmitted by breast milk and the highest risk period for
such transmission is the first few months of life (109),
the absolute transmission rates observed in the African trials
may not be comparable to what might be observed with these
regimens in HIV-1--infected women in the United States, where
breastfeeding is not recommended. However, comparison of the
percentage of reduction in transmission at early timepoints
(e.g., 4--6 weeks) may be applicable. In the effective arms of
the PETRA trial, antiretroviral drugs were administered
postnatally to both the mother and the infant to reduce the
risk of early transmission through breast milk. In the United
States, administration of ZDV-3TC to the mother postnatally in
addition to the infant would not be required for prophylaxis
against transmission because HIV-1--infected women
are--advised not to breastfeed their infants (although ZDV-3TC
might be indicated as part of a combination postnatal
treatment regimen for the woman).
Epidemiologic data from New York State indicate
that--intravenous maternal intrapartum ZDV followed by oral
ZDV for 6 weeks to the infant may significantly reduce
trans-mission compared with no treatment . Transmission rates were 10% (95% CI = 3%--22%) with intrapartum and neonatal ZDV compared with 27% (95% CI =
21%--33%) without ZDV, a 62% reduction in risk (95% CI =
19%--82%) (70,71). Similarly, in an epidemiologic study
in North Carolina, intravenous intrapartum and 6-week oral
neonatal ZDV treatment was associated with a transmission rate
of 11%, compared with 31% without therapy (6). However,
intrapartum ZDV combined with very short-term ZDV
administration to infants postnatally, e.g., the 1-week
postnatal infant ZDV course in HIVNET 012 (65), has not
proved effective to date. This underscores the necessity of
recommending a full 6-week course of infant treatment when ZDV
alone is used.
No data are available to address the relative efficacy of
these three intrapartum/neonatal antiretroviral regimens for
prevention of transmission. In the absence of data to suggest
the superiority of one or more of the possible regimens,
choice should be based upon the specific circumstances of each
woman. The 2-dose nevirapine regimen offers the--advantage of
lower cost, the possibility of directly observed therapy and
increased adherence compared with the other two regimens. In a
clinical trial (SAINT) in South Africa, which compared the
2-dose nevirapine and the intrapartum/ postpartum ZDV-3TC
regimens, no significant differences were observed between the
two regimens in terms of efficacy in reducing transmission or
in maternal and infant toxicity (66).
It has not been determined if combining intravenous
intrapartum/6-week neonatal oral ZDV with the 2-dose
nevirapine regimen will provide additional benefit over that
observed with each regimen alone. Clinical trial data have
established that combination therapy is superior to
single-drug therapy for treatment of persons with established
infection and that--infants born to women in labor who have
not received any antiretroviral therapy are at high risk for
infection. The--2-dose nevirapine regimen had no serious
short-term drug-associated toxicity in the 313 mother--infant
pairs exposed to the regimen in the HIVNET 012 trial.
Nevirapine and ZDV are synergistic in inhibiting HIV-1
replication in vitro (110), and both nevirapine and ZDV
rapidly cross the placenta to achieve drug levels in the
infant nearly equal to those in the mother. In contrast to ZDV,
nevirapine can decrease plasma HIV-1 RNA concentration by at
least 1.3 log by 7 days after a single dose (111) and
is active immediately against intracellular and extracellular
virus (112). However, nevirapine resistance can be
induced by a single mutation at codon 181, whereas high-level
resistance to ZDV requires several mutations. Nevirapine
resistance mutations were detected at 6 weeks postpartum in
19% of antiretroviral naive women and 15% of women receiving
antiretroviral drugs during pregnancy who received single-dose
nevirapine during labor (See Antiretroviral Drug Resistance
and Resistance Testing in--Pregnancy).
A theoretical benefit of combining the intrapartum/neonatal
ZDV and nevirapine regimens would be the efficacy of this
combination if the woman had acquired infection with HIV-1
that is resistant to either ZDV or nevirapine. Perinatal
transmission of antiretroviral drug-resistant virus has been
reported but appears to be unusual (6,113,114). Virus
with low-level ZDV resistance may be less likely to establish
infection than wild-type virus, and transmission may not occur
even when maternal virus has high-level ZDV resistance (114--117).
Since the prevalence of drug-resistant virus is an evolving
phenomenon, surveillance is needed to determine this
prevalence in pregnant women over time and the risk of
transmission of resistant viral strains. The potential
benefits of combination prophylaxis with intrapartum/neonatal
nevirapine and ZDV must be weighed against the increased cost,
possible problems with nonadherence, potential short- and
long-term toxicity, including the risk of emergence of
nevirapine-resistant virus, and the lack of definitive data to
show that combining the two intrapartum/postpartum regimens
offers any additional benefit for prevention of transmission
over the use of either drug alone.
4. Infants Born to Mothers Who Have Received No
Antiretroviral Therapy During Pregnancy or Intrapartum
Recommendation. The 6-week neonatal component of the
ZDV chemoprophylactic regimen should be discussed with the
mother and offered for the newborn. ZDV should be--initiated
as soon as possible after delivery, preferably within 6--12
hours of birth. Some clinicians may use ZDV in combination
with other antiretroviral drugs, particularly if the mother is
known or suspected to have ZDV-resistant virus. However, the
efficacy of this approach for prevention of transmission is
unknown, and appropriate dosing regimens for neonates are
incompletely defined. In the immediate postpartum period, the
woman should undergo appropriate assessments (e.g., CD4+
count and HIV-1 RNA copy number) to determine if
antiretroviral therapy is required for her own health.
The--infant should undergo early diagnostic testing so that if
he or she is HIV-1 infected, treatment can be initiated as
soon as--possible.
Discussion. Definitive data are not available to
address whether ZDV administered only during the neonatal
period would reduce the risk of perinatal transmission.
Epidemiologic data from a New York State study indicate a
decline in transmission when infants were given ZDV for the
first 6 weeks of life compared with no prophylaxis (70,71).
Transmission rates were 9% (95% CI = 4.1%--17.5%) with ZDV
prophylaxis of newborns only (initiated within 48 hours after
birth) versus 18% (95% CI = 7.7%--34.3%) with prophylaxis
initiated after 48 hours, and 27% (95% CI = 21%--33%) with--no
ZDV prophylaxis (70). Epidemiologic data from North
Carolina did not demonstrate a benefit of ZDV for newborns
only compared with no prophylaxis (6). Transmission
rates were 27% (95% CI = 8%--55%) with prophylaxis of newborns
only and 31% (95% CI = 24%--39%) with no prophylaxis. The
timing of initiation of infant prophylaxis was not defined in
this study. Data from a case-control study of postexposure
prophylaxis of health-care workers who had nosocomial
percutaneous exposure to blood from HIV-1--infected persons
indicate that ZDV administration was associated with a 79%
reduction in the risk for HIV-1 seroconversion following
exposure Postexposure prophylaxis also has prevented retroviral
infection in some studies involving animals (118--120).
The interval during which benefit can be gained from
postexposure prophylaxis is undefined. When prophylaxis was
delayed beyond 48 hours after birth in the New York State
study, no efficacy could be demonstrated. For most infants in
this study, prophylaxis was initiated within 24 hours (71).
Data from studies of animals indicate that the longer the
delay in institution of prophylaxis, the less likely that
infection will be prevented. In most studies of animals,
antiretroviral prophylaxis initiated 24--36 hours after
exposure has usually not been effective for preventing
infection, although later administration has been associated
with decreased viremia (118--120). In cats, ZDV
treatment initiated within the first 4 days after challenge
with feline leukemia virus afforded protection, whereas
treatment initiated 1 week postexposure did not (121).
The relevance of these animal studies to prevention of
perinatal HIV-1 transmission in humans is unknown. HIV-1
infection is established in most infected infants by age 1--2
weeks. In a study of 271 infected infants, HIV-1 DNA
polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was positive in 38% of samples
from infants tested within 48 hours of birth. No substantial
change in diagnostic sensitivity was observed within the first
week of life, but detection increased rapidly during the
second week of life, reaching 93% by age 14 days (122).
Initiation of postexposure prophylaxis after age 2 days is not
likely to be efficacious in preventing transmission, and by
age 14 days, infection would already be established in most
infants.
When the mother has received neither the antenatal nor
intrapartum parts of the three-part ZDV regimen,
administration of antiretroviral drugs to the newborn provides
chemoprophylaxis only after HIV-1 exposure has already
occurred. Some clinicians view this situation as analogous to
nosocomial postexposure prophylaxis and may wish to provide
ZDV in combination with one or more other antiretroviral
agents. Such a decision must be accompanied by a discussion
with the woman of the potential benefits and risks of this
approach and the lack of data to address its efficacy and
safety.
Antiretroviral Drug Resistance and
Resistance Testing in Pregnancy
The development of antiretroviral drug resistance is one of
the major factors leading to therapy failure in
HIV-1--infected persons. Resistant viral variants emerge under
selective pressure, especially with incompletely suppressive
regimens,--because of the inherent mutation-prone process of
reverse transcription with viral replication. The
administration of combination antiretroviral therapy with
maximal suppression of viral replication to undetectable
levels limits the development of antiretroviral resistance in
both pregnant and nonpregnant persons. Some have raised
concern that using non-highly--active antiretroviral regimens,
such as ZDV monotherapy, for prophylaxis against perinatal
|