|
A culture of safety
To
err is human, but to report is no longer
"divine" – it's expected. The
AMA is working to reduce medical errors and
improve reporting protocol
|
One of the driving
forces behind the National Patient Safety
Foundation (NSPF) is the Hippocratic Oath, which
commands physicians "Above all, do not
harm."
Now read that
sentence again. There are two errors: one is
fairly obvious to the average physician, the other
more elusive* (see end of article for answers.)
The point of this exercise: everyone makes
mistakes, even doctors. But how should we handle
errors when they are not easily remedied with a
stroke of the “delete” key? The answer,
according to AMA Trustee Timothy T Flaherty, MD, “is to acknowledge errors
when they do occur, and use the opportunity to
figure out how not to let them happen again.”
According to a recent
study from the national standards-setting
organization U.S. Pharmacopeia, while U.S.
hospitals and health care systems have improved
their track record of reporting medication errors,
they continue to make the same mistakes over and
over. The most common mistakes reported: omission
errors.
And though less than
one percent of reported errors result in patient
death, the AMA believes that any error that harms
a patient is one error too many. In keeping with
this belief, we have pioneered the effort to
reduce health care system errors and ensure that
patients receive safe, quality health care.
In 1996, the AMA
partnered with other organizations to convene an
inaugural multidisciplinary conference on errors
in health care, spawning numerous patient safety
initiatives at both the state and national level.
In 1997, with the help of CNA HealthPro, 3M and
the Schering-Plough Corporation, the AMA
established the National Patient Safety Foundation
(NPSF), an independent, non-profit organization
representing clinicians, consumer advocates,
health product manufacturers, policymakers and
more, with the ultimate goal of promoting patient
safety to the nation’s top priority.
“The sort of first
commandment for doctors is ‘First, do no
harm,’” explained Tom Houston, MD, director of
Science and Community Health Advocacy for the AMA.
“The major thrust of what physicians do springs
from that. Whatever physicians can do, and
whatever the systems within which physicians work
can do to improve and maintain patient safety as a
cornerstone of medical care, the AMA wants to
accomplish.” Dr. Houston added that cooperation
from the health community at large is essential.
Hospitals, physicians, nurses, pharmacists, drug
and device manufacturers, nursing homes, and
others must unite to identify, study, and solve
system-wide problems that could cause errors or
adverse outcomes.
Towards this end, in
2000 the AMA joined with more than 20 other
national health care organizations to form a
coalition to develop a set of General Principles
for Patient Safety Reporting Systems that
underscore the point that, for error reporting
systems to be successful, they must be constructed
in a non-punitive manner that provide appropriate
confidentiality protections. Congress can help
create a “culture of safety” by encouraging
medical professionals to convene to discuss
patient safety problems and potential solutions
without having their discussions, findings, or
recommendations become the basis for class action
or other lawsuits. The AMA strongly believes that
a confidential, non-retaliatory, evidence-based
system for reporting health care errors will
improve care and prevent future oversights.
“With so much attention being paid today to
professional liability reform, any one of us might
hesitate to admit that we have ever committed a
medical error,” Dr. Flaherty said. The focus
must remain on widespread system reform, rather
than individual punishment.
Such strategies, Dr.
Houston said, are “integral to making sure
patient safety is enforced throughout the health
care environment, from the pharmacy to the
operating room, from legibility of medical records
and prescriptions to safe anesthesiology
procedures.”
The latest effort to
cut down on medical errors: the Patient Safety and
Quality Improvement Act introduced in the Senate
early this summer, under which medical
professionals would be able to report mistakes
confidentially. Reporting would be made to private
"patient safety organizations," or PSOs
– groups authorized to collect and analyze
patient safety information on a confidential
basis, and deed the data back to health care
organizations. The NPSF would be one such group.
Ensuring
confidentiality and protection from lawsuits is
critical to encouraging more health care providers
to volunteer information about patient safety,
Sen. James Jeffords (I, Vt.), one of the bill's
sponsors, told AMNews. “If you don't get the
information, you can't address the problems.”
Similar legislation has been introduced in the
House.
The AMA is committed
to continuing and redoubling our efforts to work
with Congress and our partners in the health care
system to achieve an environment in which patients
are assured of safe, quality health care.
* The
National Patient Safety Foundation is NPSF,
and the Hippocratic oath says "Above all, do no
harm."
|